Home Addition Cost & Bid Comparison Calculator

Compare two contractor bids for the same home addition. Enter the quoted prices and identify where a package such as finishes, utility work or a permit is included, provisional or excluded. Use your own low, base and high estimates for the common scope. The planner shows the normalized contract, owner costs and reserve so you can compare the full project budgets and see what fits.

Home addition estimates

Compare home addition bids on the same scope

Project and bid amounts

Use common owner costs for expenses outside both quotes, such as design fees and permits. Count each amount once.

Scope and allowances

Enter the same expected scope for both bids. Firm prices already include that work. Allowances are replaced by your estimate. Excluded work is added outside the bid.

Finish materials
Utility connection

Base project budgets: Bid A $182,600.00, Bid B $172,150.00.

Project budget comparison

Bid A · Base with reserve
$182,600.00
$456.50 per added sq ft
Bid B · Base with reserve
$172,150.00
$430.38 per added sq ft
Low-to-high budget ranges · available budget $180,000.00

Bid B uses $10,450.00 less of the budget in this scenario.

Bid A

$2,600.00 above available budget

Low
$176,550.00
Base · selected
$182,600.00
High
$194,700.00

Bid B

$7,850.00 within available budget

Low
$168,850.00
Base · selected
$172,150.00
High
$178,750.00

Bid reconciliation

Base cost itemBid ABid B
Quoted contract$142,000.00$145,500.00
Remove embedded allowances-$8,000.00-$12,000.00
Add estimated allowance selections$12,000.00$12,000.00
Normalized contract$146,000.00$145,500.00
Excluded work paid separately$9,000.00$0.00
Common owner costs$11,000.00$11,000.00
Reserve$16,600.00$15,650.00
Project budget with reserve$182,600.00$172,150.00
Project budget per added sq ft$456.50$430.38

How to use this calculator

  1. Enter added finished area, the amount available to fund the job, common owner costs, reserve percentage and both quoted prices.
  2. Add scope packages where the bid terms differ. Use the same low, base and high estimated cost for each package across both bids.
  3. Assign each bid a treatment for each package. Enter the actual embedded allowance only for a bid that already includes that provisional amount.
  4. Compare the budget ranges. Select Low, Base or High to inspect the corresponding cost per square foot and reconciliation.
  5. Download the bid CSV to retain the terms, scope treatments and all six scenario calculations.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

Enter each bid as originally quoted, including any stated allowances. For an item included at a firm price, keep that cost in the bid. For an item provided as an allowance, remove its embedded amount and add the same scope estimate used for the scenario. For an excluded item, add its estimated cost outside that bid. All allowance costs should use a comparable scope, including any applicable taxes, labor and markups.

For each bid and scenario, normalized contract = quoted amount − embedded allowances + replacement allowance estimates. Cost before reserve = normalized contract + excluded items + common owner costs. Reserve = cost before reserve × entered reserve rate divided by 100, rounded to cents half up. Project budget with reserve = cost before reserve + reserve. Remaining budget equals available budget minus project budget with reserve. Cost per added square foot divides the project budget with reserve by the added finished area and rounds to cents.

Enter up to eight packages. Amounts allow $0 to $10 million, area allows 0.01 to 100,000 square feet, and reserve accepts 0% to 100%, each with up to two decimals. Low, base and high estimates for a package must be in ascending order and may coincide. The range reflects the inputs you enter. Model your own written prices, purchase terms and scope, including any applicable cost or fees once. Time of payments, financing costs and location-specific permit or contracting rules are outside the comparison.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Project: 400 added finished sq ft, $180,000 available, $11,000 shared owner costs and 10% reserve
  • Bid A: $142,000 with $8,000 finish allowance and utility connection excluded
  • Bid B: $145,500 with $12,000 finish allowance and utility connection included at a firm price
  • Base scope estimates: $12,000 finish materials and $9,000 utility connection

Result:

The base project budget with reserve is $182,600.00 for Bid A and $172,150.00 for Bid B. After matching scope, Bid B uses $10,450.00 less of the budget. Bid A is $2,600.00 above the available amount, while Bid B leaves $7,850.00 available. The base budget per added square foot is $456.50 for Bid A and $430.38 for Bid B.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is an allowance different from a firm price?

An allowance is a provisional amount already in the quoted price. In the comparison, replace it with the low, base or high cost for that package. Firm work stays in the quoted price.

What should count as a common owner cost?

Enter costs that sit outside both written bids, such as separately contracted design, surveys or permits. Record a cost specific to just one bid as a scope package instead.

Why can the lower quote cost more for the whole addition?

A low quoted amount may leave some work for the owner or include smaller allowances. The normalized comparison accounts for the same work and reserve under both bid structures.

How should I use the cost per square foot?

Divide the scenario's full project budget by the added finished area. Use a consistent definition of area and scope when comparing the resulting numbers.

What does the high scenario represent?

The high scenario uses the high numbers you entered for every non-firm package and adds the selected reserve. Enter quotes and reasonable ranges for the scope you expect to build.

Similar Calculators