Home Equity Loan Calculator

Decide what changes when you keep your existing mortgage and add a fixed home equity loan, or replace it with a larger cash-out refinance. Match the cash each option leaves you after closing costs, or find the most net cash each can provide under an assumed equity ceiling. Compare both at the same holding period to see the payment, interest and fees, and mortgage debt that remains. Enter your own rates and fees; the examples are illustrative assumptions.

Home equity comparison

Keep your mortgage—or replace it?

Compare a fixed home equity loan with a cash-out refinance, including the cost of the mortgage you already have.

All dollar amounts are USD. Rates are fixed note rates. Use the rates and fees from your comparison scenarios. The model checks your entered debt ceiling and leaves eligibility to the lender.

Month 60: home equity strategy cost $53,694.78, refinance cost $92,952.99.

Compare cash at closing

Both offers use the same advance before upfront fees. Upfront fees come from existing funds, so the net cash you keep can differ.

Home equity loan payment

$482.60 / month

Initially $1,869.10 including your existing mortgage.

Refinance payment

$1,816.64 / month

Replaces the existing mortgage and funds the cash advance.

Cost difference at month 60

$39,258.21

Less interest + fees keeping the mortgage. Compare cash paid and remaining debt below.

Your starting point

Enter the remaining balance and term of a fully amortizing fixed-rate mortgage. Use zero balance if there is no current mortgage. For refinancing, the entered balance also serves as the estimated payoff. Check your servicer’s payoff quote for accrued interest or other amounts due.

A · Keep mortgage + add home equity loan

Your current mortgage keeps its entered rate and remaining term.

B · Replace with cash-out refinance

The new rate applies to the current balance as well as the cash advance.

Limits: current balance $0–10m. Same advance $0–5m or equal net cash target $0–50m. Each fee $0–1m, entered in cents. Note rates 0–40% with up to six decimal places. Terms 1–600 whole months; comparison month 0–600. No taxes, insurance, variable rates, penalties or lender cent rounding.

Home value $0.01–50m; assumed CLTV 1–100%. The ceiling applies to the current balance and new debt including financed fees. Both offers use the same ceiling.

Debt ceiling: $400,000.00.

A: $300,500.00 combined debt · $99,500.00 headroom.

B: $303,000.00 debt · $97,000.00 headroom.

Your comparison horizon

Compare from closing (month 0) through month 600. A loan that has already been paid off adds no later payment or interest.

See what a lower payment leaves behind

Solid blue: keep mortgage + home equity loan. Dashed purple: cash-out refinance. All values are nominal USD. No discount rate or investment return is assumed.

0178K356KUSD0180360 mo

Fees are included from month 0. Payments stop after each loan term. Monthly payment is a step series; interest and balance are sampled after each month-end payment.

Month 60 · cash, debt and cost

A keeps the mortgage; B refinances it
MeasureA · Home equityB · Refinance
Net closing cash$49,000.00$48,000.00
Payment in selected month$1,869.10$1,816.64
Cash paid incl. upfront fees$113,145.90$110,998.29
Debt still owed$240,548.88$281,954.70
Interest accrued$52,194.78$87,952.99
All fees$1,500.00$5,000.00
Financing cost: interest + fees$53,694.78$92,952.99
Lifetime interest + fees$120,627.33$355,989.71

Financing cost is interest plus all fees. Principal repayment is not a financing cost; it reduces the debt you owe. Upfront fees affect immediate liquidity, while financed fees also accrue interest. A negative net closing cash figure means fees paid from existing funds exceed the advance.

Monthly comparison ledger

Months 0–23 of 360

Complete monthly ledger, 24 months per page
MonthA paymentB paymentA debtB debtA costB cost
$0.00$0.00$300,500.00$303,000.00$1,500.00$5,000.00
$1,869.10$1,816.64$299,592.57$302,698.36$2,461.67$6,515.00
$1,869.10$1,816.64$298,682.26$302,395.22$3,420.46$8,028.49
$1,869.10$1,816.64$297,769.06$302,090.55$4,376.36$9,540.47
$1,869.10$1,816.64$296,852.97$301,784.37$5,329.36$11,050.92
$1,869.10$1,816.64$295,933.96$301,476.65$6,279.45$12,559.84
$1,869.10$1,816.64$295,012.03$301,167.40$7,226.62$14,067.23
$1,869.10$1,816.64$294,087.17$300,856.60$8,170.86$15,573.06
$1,869.10$1,816.64$293,159.37$300,544.24$9,112.15$17,077.35
$1,869.10$1,816.64$292,228.60$300,230.32$10,050.49$18,580.07
$1,869.10$1,816.64$291,294.87$299,914.84$10,985.86$20,081.22
$1,869.10$1,816.64$290,358.16$299,597.77$11,918.24$21,580.79
$1,869.10$1,816.64$289,418.46$299,279.12$12,847.64$23,078.78
$1,869.10$1,816.64$288,475.75$298,958.88$13,774.03$24,575.18
$1,869.10$1,816.64$287,530.03$298,637.04$14,697.41$26,069.97
$1,869.10$1,816.64$286,581.28$298,313.59$15,617.76$27,563.16
$1,869.10$1,816.64$285,629.50$297,988.52$16,535.07$29,054.72
$1,869.10$1,816.64$284,674.66$297,661.82$17,449.33$30,544.67
$1,869.10$1,816.64$283,716.76$297,333.49$18,360.52$32,032.98
$1,869.10$1,816.64$282,755.78$297,003.52$19,268.64$33,519.64
$1,869.10$1,816.64$281,791.71$296,671.90$20,173.68$35,004.66
$1,869.10$1,816.64$280,824.55$296,338.62$21,075.61$36,488.02
$1,869.10$1,816.64$279,854.27$296,003.68$21,974.43$37,969.71
$1,869.10$1,816.64$278,880.86$295,667.06$22,870.13$39,449.73

Keep the complete comparison

CSV includes inputs, assumptions and the calculated equity limits where applicable. When a common cash comparison is available, it includes every monthly row of all three loans. Extra digits show the model’s calculation precision.

How to use this calculator

  1. Enter your current fixed mortgage balance, annual note rate and remaining whole months. The refinance calculation uses that balance as its estimated payoff.
  2. Enter both offers and separate the fees you pay with your own funds from the fees added to each loan. Use the fixed note rate.
  3. Choose Same cash advance before fees to compare equal gross advances. Choose Same cash after fees to enter your desired net cash and compare the actual amounts each offer would need to finance.
  4. Choose Maximum net cash and enter home value and an assumed combined loan-to-value ceiling to see what each offer yields. Any schedules in this mode use the largest net cash amount both offers can support.
  5. Choose a comparison month. Use the timeline to inspect monthly payments, remaining debt and costs at that same horizon. Expand the monthly ledger or download the CSV for details.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

The monthly rate r is the annual nominal note rate divided by 1,200. For principal P and n payments, monthly payment is Pr / [1 − (1+r)^(−n)], or P/n at zero rate. Payments occur at month end and a zero balance has no payment.
Home equity loan principal equals its gross advance plus financed home equity fees. The existing mortgage stays on its current amortization schedule. Cash-out refinance principal equals the assumed payoff plus its gross advance and financed refinance fees. The entered current mortgage balance serves as that payoff estimate. Net cash to you equals the gross advance minus any upfront fees you pay with your own money.
Use Same cash advance before fees for a common gross advance. With Same cash after fees, each gross advance equals your desired net cash plus that offer’s upfront fees. Financed fees are already accounted for in principal. Enter fees as fixed dollar amounts for the intended loan size, including any points in the appropriate fee field.
For maximum net cash, multiply the assumed home value by the combined LTV limit and round down to the whole cent. For each offer, subtract current mortgage debt and financed fees from that ceiling to find gross room. A negative gross room means the modeled debt alone exceeds the ceiling. Otherwise subtract upfront fees to get maximum net cash. Negative net means money is due from you, and zero means the transaction covers fees with no cash out. When both offers fit a nonnegative net amount, use the smaller of their maxima for the common-horizon schedule. Each strategy’s individual maximum remains visible.
At month H, financing cost is interest accrued plus upfront and financed fees. The same result equals payments to date plus debt remaining plus upfront fees minus original mortgage principal and that strategy’s gross advance. Positive refinance advantage means refinancing has lower interest plus fees at the chosen horizon. Fees are included from closing, monetary values are USD and the comparison uses nominal cash flows. Amortization retains full precision without lender-specific cent rounding.
The cap is a user-entered planning assumption. The model uses one entered existing mortgage, the same assumed combined LTV for both options, and fixed rates and costs. Actual cash to close may differ with the full payoff quote, credits, escrow or other items shown on the lender’s closing documents.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Existing mortgage: $250,000 at 3%, 240 months remaining
  • Cash advance: $50,000 before upfront fees
  • Home equity loan: 8%, 180 months; $1,000 upfront fees + $500 financed fees
  • Cash-out refinance: 6%, 360 months; $2,000 upfront fees + $3,000 financed fees
  • Comparison month: 60
  • Equity assumption: $500,000 home value; 80% maximum combined LTV

Result:

The home equity loan payment is $482.60 per month; together with the existing mortgage, the initial monthly payment is $1,869.10. Refinancing requires $1,816.64 per month. At month 60, keeping the mortgage has $53,694.78 of interest plus fees and $240,548.88 of debt remaining. Refinancing has $92,952.99 of interest plus fees and $281,954.70 of debt remaining. Keeping the mortgage costs $39,258.21 less over this five-year comparison, despite its larger initial payment. Net closing cash is $49,000 versus $48,000 after the separately paid upfront fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is this different from the HELOC calculator?

This tool compares two fixed-rate, fully amortizing lump-sum alternatives. A home equity loan adds a second payment while retaining your current mortgage. A cash-out refinance replaces that mortgage and funds the advance in one new loan. The separate HELOC calculator models a revolving draw period and later repayment; this page does not model repeated advances or variable-rate resets.

Why can refinancing have a lower payment but cost more?

A longer repayment term can reduce the monthly payment while leaving more principal unpaid and accumulating more interest. Refinancing also changes the rate on the entire existing balance. Compare interest plus fees and remaining debt at the same month, not just initial payments. Compare actual written offers and the full payment obligation. A lower nominal cost does not incorporate affordability or future plans.

How do I compare equal net cash from both loans?

Choose Same cash after fees and enter what you want to keep. For $50,000 net, an offer with $1,000 of cash-paid fees needs a $51,000 advance. An offer with $2,000 of cash-paid fees needs $52,000. Any financed fees are added on top of those amounts.

How much can I cash out under an assumed equity ceiling?

Choose Maximum net cash. With a $400,000 ceiling and $250,000 existing balance, $3,000 of financed fees leaves $147,000 of gross room. After $2,000 in upfront fees, maximum net cash is $145,000. When the two offer limits differ, the schedules compare their largest shared net amount.

How are fees and outstanding principal counted?

Financed fees raise principal and accrue interest. All upfront and financed fees are included once in financing cost from month 0. Principal repayment is not counted as a financing cost; it reduces debt. Cash paid and remaining debt are shown separately so a slowly repaid loan does not gain an artificial advantage. The CSV retains the individual loan schedules and both strategies when a common net cash comparison is available.

Does the equity ceiling tell me how much a lender will approve?

The ceiling compares modeled debt with home value times your assumed combined LTV, including financed fees. The lender sets its own eligibility and valuation rules. A gross or equal-net target above the ceiling shows the amount over and a hypothetical schedule. Maximum mode distinguishes debt already over the ceiling from a closing that still requires your cash to pay fees.

What if I enter zero interest, no current mortgage, or a later holding period?

Zero interest divides principal evenly over the term. A zero current balance creates no existing mortgage payment. All schedules stop payments at their respective payoffs; a holding period beyond payoff adds no further interest. Month 0 shows fees and initial debt before any payment. Values are calculated without rounding each month to cents.

Which inputs and loan features are supported?

USD balances accept cents: current mortgage up to $10 million, gross advance up to $5 million in the original mode, equal net cash target up to $50 million and each fee up to $1 million. Note rates range from 0 to 40% with up to six decimal places. Terms are 1–600 whole months, with a comparison month from 0 to 600. The model excludes escrow, insurance, taxes, deductions, daily accrual, payment rounding, variable rates, balloons, prepayment penalties and extra payments. The example rates are assumptions, not market offers.

Similar Calculators