Roof Replacement Cost & Quote Comparison Calculator
A low roof replacement quote can change when excluded work or hidden decking repairs are added. Compare up to four actual quotes for the same roof and repair billing unit. Separate included work from additional priced work, unknown scope and exclusions; inspect base costs, extra repairs and your optional budget reserve. A repair-count chart and exact price intervals show where a different quote becomes less expensive, while budget limits distinguish a true cutoff from the end of your chosen comparison range. All prices are entered assumptions, not local market estimates. Scope readiness means the listed work has been accounted for; it does not certify equivalent products, installation quality, warranties, structural suitability or code compliance.
See what changes when the decking comes off
Compare quoted work, repair allowances and the budget you need for uncertain decking repairs.
Use tax-inclusive prices for the same measured roof and repair billing unit. A lower modeled price does not establish equal products, workmanship, warranties or suitability. These examples are assumptions, not local market prices.
Your repair scenario
Label only; amounts are not converted.
Whole billable units, including any allowance.
0–10,000; must include the current scenario.
0–100%. Applied to known costs, rounded up to a cent. Not a contractor charge.
Confirm the same panel size, material, thickness, removal and installed repair work for every quote. This is not a sheet takeoff.
Enter and clarify each quote
Already includes items marked Included below; do not add them twice.
Record product/system, tear-off scope, access assumptions and warranty differences. Price readiness does not verify equivalence.
Comparison updated for 12 repair units. Lowest priced ready quote: Quote B.
Costs at 12 repair units
Quote A
Illustrative complete roof-system quote; verify actual product and warranty scope
Known costs plus budget reserve
USD 12,390.00
Contractor subtotal USD 11,800.00 · reserve USD 590.00
Scope ready for price comparison
Up to 15 repair units fit; 16 exceeds budget
Budget headroom: USD 610.00
Quote B
Illustrative complete roof-system quote; verify actual product and warranty scope
Known costs plus budget reserve
USD 11,718.00
Contractor subtotal USD 11,160.00 · reserve USD 558.00
Lowest priced scope-ready quote
Up to 27 repair units fit; 28 exceeds budget
Budget headroom: USD 1,282.00
Quote A: cost breakdown
12 extra units billed after 0 included units. All entered prices include their applicable taxes.
What happens as decking repairs increase?
Budget total in USD, including the entered reserve. Each marker is a whole repair-unit scenario; connecting lines are guides. Incomplete quotes show known costs only. The black dashed line is your budget. The vertical gray line is the current scenario.
Lowest priced scope-ready quotes by repair count
- 0–6 units: Quote A
- 7–40 units: Quote B
Inspect complete sampled cost table
| Repair units | Quote | Known subtotal | Reserve | Budget total | Headroom |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Quote A | USD 10,000.00 | USD 500.00 | USD 10,500.00 | USD 2,500.00 |
| 0 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 1 | Quote A | USD 10,150.00 | USD 507.50 | USD 10,657.50 | USD 2,342.50 |
| 1 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 2 | Quote A | USD 10,300.00 | USD 515.00 | USD 10,815.00 | USD 2,185.00 |
| 2 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 3 | Quote A | USD 10,450.00 | USD 522.50 | USD 10,972.50 | USD 2,027.50 |
| 3 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 4 | Quote A | USD 10,600.00 | USD 530.00 | USD 11,130.00 | USD 1,870.00 |
| 4 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 5 | Quote A | USD 10,750.00 | USD 537.50 | USD 11,287.50 | USD 1,712.50 |
| 5 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 6 | Quote A | USD 10,900.00 | USD 545.00 | USD 11,445.00 | USD 1,555.00 |
| 6 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 7 | Quote A | USD 11,050.00 | USD 552.50 | USD 11,602.50 | USD 1,397.50 |
| 7 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 8 | Quote A | USD 11,200.00 | USD 560.00 | USD 11,760.00 | USD 1,240.00 |
| 8 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 9 | Quote A | USD 11,350.00 | USD 567.50 | USD 11,917.50 | USD 1,082.50 |
| 9 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 10 | Quote A | USD 11,500.00 | USD 575.00 | USD 12,075.00 | USD 925.00 |
| 10 | Quote B | USD 11,000.00 | USD 550.00 | USD 11,550.00 | USD 1,450.00 |
| 11 | Quote A | USD 11,650.00 | USD 582.50 | USD 12,232.50 | USD 767.50 |
| 11 | Quote B | USD 11,080.00 | USD 554.00 | USD 11,634.00 | USD 1,366.00 |
| 12 | Quote A | USD 11,800.00 | USD 590.00 | USD 12,390.00 | USD 610.00 |
| 12 | Quote B | USD 11,160.00 | USD 558.00 | USD 11,718.00 | USD 1,282.00 |
| 13 | Quote A | USD 11,950.00 | USD 597.50 | USD 12,547.50 | USD 452.50 |
| 13 | Quote B | USD 11,240.00 | USD 562.00 | USD 11,802.00 | USD 1,198.00 |
| 14 | Quote A | USD 12,100.00 | USD 605.00 | USD 12,705.00 | USD 295.00 |
| 14 | Quote B | USD 11,320.00 | USD 566.00 | USD 11,886.00 | USD 1,114.00 |
| 15 | Quote A | USD 12,250.00 | USD 612.50 | USD 12,862.50 | USD 137.50 |
| 15 | Quote B | USD 11,400.00 | USD 570.00 | USD 11,970.00 | USD 1,030.00 |
| 16 | Quote A | USD 12,400.00 | USD 620.00 | USD 13,020.00 | −USD 20.00 |
| 16 | Quote B | USD 11,480.00 | USD 574.00 | USD 12,054.00 | USD 946.00 |
| 17 | Quote A | USD 12,550.00 | USD 627.50 | USD 13,177.50 | −USD 177.50 |
| 17 | Quote B | USD 11,560.00 | USD 578.00 | USD 12,138.00 | USD 862.00 |
| 18 | Quote A | USD 12,700.00 | USD 635.00 | USD 13,335.00 | −USD 335.00 |
| 18 | Quote B | USD 11,640.00 | USD 582.00 | USD 12,222.00 | USD 778.00 |
| 19 | Quote A | USD 12,850.00 | USD 642.50 | USD 13,492.50 | −USD 492.50 |
| 19 | Quote B | USD 11,720.00 | USD 586.00 | USD 12,306.00 | USD 694.00 |
| 20 | Quote A | USD 13,000.00 | USD 650.00 | USD 13,650.00 | −USD 650.00 |
| 20 | Quote B | USD 11,800.00 | USD 590.00 | USD 12,390.00 | USD 610.00 |
| 21 | Quote A | USD 13,150.00 | USD 657.50 | USD 13,807.50 | −USD 807.50 |
| 21 | Quote B | USD 11,880.00 | USD 594.00 | USD 12,474.00 | USD 526.00 |
| 22 | Quote A | USD 13,300.00 | USD 665.00 | USD 13,965.00 | −USD 965.00 |
| 22 | Quote B | USD 11,960.00 | USD 598.00 | USD 12,558.00 | USD 442.00 |
| 23 | Quote A | USD 13,450.00 | USD 672.50 | USD 14,122.50 | −USD 1,122.50 |
| 23 | Quote B | USD 12,040.00 | USD 602.00 | USD 12,642.00 | USD 358.00 |
| 24 | Quote A | USD 13,600.00 | USD 680.00 | USD 14,280.00 | −USD 1,280.00 |
| 24 | Quote B | USD 12,120.00 | USD 606.00 | USD 12,726.00 | USD 274.00 |
| 25 | Quote A | USD 13,750.00 | USD 687.50 | USD 14,437.50 | −USD 1,437.50 |
| 25 | Quote B | USD 12,200.00 | USD 610.00 | USD 12,810.00 | USD 190.00 |
| 26 | Quote A | USD 13,900.00 | USD 695.00 | USD 14,595.00 | −USD 1,595.00 |
| 26 | Quote B | USD 12,280.00 | USD 614.00 | USD 12,894.00 | USD 106.00 |
| 27 | Quote A | USD 14,050.00 | USD 702.50 | USD 14,752.50 | −USD 1,752.50 |
| 27 | Quote B | USD 12,360.00 | USD 618.00 | USD 12,978.00 | USD 22.00 |
| 28 | Quote A | USD 14,200.00 | USD 710.00 | USD 14,910.00 | −USD 1,910.00 |
| 28 | Quote B | USD 12,440.00 | USD 622.00 | USD 13,062.00 | −USD 62.00 |
| 29 | Quote A | USD 14,350.00 | USD 717.50 | USD 15,067.50 | −USD 2,067.50 |
| 29 | Quote B | USD 12,520.00 | USD 626.00 | USD 13,146.00 | −USD 146.00 |
| 30 | Quote A | USD 14,500.00 | USD 725.00 | USD 15,225.00 | −USD 2,225.00 |
| 30 | Quote B | USD 12,600.00 | USD 630.00 | USD 13,230.00 | −USD 230.00 |
| 31 | Quote A | USD 14,650.00 | USD 732.50 | USD 15,382.50 | −USD 2,382.50 |
| 31 | Quote B | USD 12,680.00 | USD 634.00 | USD 13,314.00 | −USD 314.00 |
| 32 | Quote A | USD 14,800.00 | USD 740.00 | USD 15,540.00 | −USD 2,540.00 |
| 32 | Quote B | USD 12,760.00 | USD 638.00 | USD 13,398.00 | −USD 398.00 |
| 33 | Quote A | USD 14,950.00 | USD 747.50 | USD 15,697.50 | −USD 2,697.50 |
| 33 | Quote B | USD 12,840.00 | USD 642.00 | USD 13,482.00 | −USD 482.00 |
| 34 | Quote A | USD 15,100.00 | USD 755.00 | USD 15,855.00 | −USD 2,855.00 |
| 34 | Quote B | USD 12,920.00 | USD 646.00 | USD 13,566.00 | −USD 566.00 |
| 35 | Quote A | USD 15,250.00 | USD 762.50 | USD 16,012.50 | −USD 3,012.50 |
| 35 | Quote B | USD 13,000.00 | USD 650.00 | USD 13,650.00 | −USD 650.00 |
| 36 | Quote A | USD 15,400.00 | USD 770.00 | USD 16,170.00 | −USD 3,170.00 |
| 36 | Quote B | USD 13,080.00 | USD 654.00 | USD 13,734.00 | −USD 734.00 |
| 37 | Quote A | USD 15,550.00 | USD 777.50 | USD 16,327.50 | −USD 3,327.50 |
| 37 | Quote B | USD 13,160.00 | USD 658.00 | USD 13,818.00 | −USD 818.00 |
| 38 | Quote A | USD 15,700.00 | USD 785.00 | USD 16,485.00 | −USD 3,485.00 |
| 38 | Quote B | USD 13,240.00 | USD 662.00 | USD 13,902.00 | −USD 902.00 |
| 39 | Quote A | USD 15,850.00 | USD 792.50 | USD 16,642.50 | −USD 3,642.50 |
| 39 | Quote B | USD 13,320.00 | USD 666.00 | USD 13,986.00 | −USD 986.00 |
| 40 | Quote A | USD 16,000.00 | USD 800.00 | USD 16,800.00 | −USD 3,800.00 |
| 40 | Quote B | USD 13,400.00 | USD 670.00 | USD 14,070.00 | −USD 1,070.00 |
Scope comparison
| Work | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Old roofing removal | included | included |
| Disposal | included | included |
| Flashing work | included | included |
| Ventilation work | included | included |
| Permits | included | included |
| Site cleanup | included | included |
Keep the comparison
Export assumptions, scope notes, cost breakdowns, budget limits, ranking intervals and every chart sample. CSV money outputs use exact integer cents.
How this comparison works
Extra repair cost = max(0, repair units − included units) × quoted unit price. Known subtotal adds the base quote and scope items marked Additional. Budget reserve is the entered percentage of that subtotal, rounded up to a cent. Budget total adds the reserve. Exact cent comparisons preserve ties and one-cent budget boundaries.
Every whole repair count through your maximum is checked for the lowest priced scope-ready quote. Budget limits apply only within that range. Unknown and excluded work prevents a complete-price ranking; Not required is your stated assumption, not a code determination. Other hidden damage, financing and insurance payments are not modeled.
Source context reviewed November 18, 2026: GAF roof estimate scope and hidden decking repair costs. All numerical prices and repair scenarios here are user-entered assumptions.
How to use this calculator
- Start with Allowance crossover example or Incomplete quote example. Select Price currency, Current repair units, Maximum repair units to compare, Available budget and Additional budget reserve. The example prices are editable assumptions.
- Describe the Shared decking repair billing unit, including panel size, material, thickness and the removal/installation work where relevant. Confirm that each contractor prices the same unit; this is not a sheet-cutting or damage-area calculation.
- Use Quote to edit and inspect to enter each quote name, tax-inclusive base price, included repair units and extra-unit price. Record roof system and quote conditions so product and warranty differences remain visible.
- Classify removal, disposal, flashing, ventilation, permits and cleanup. Included work stays inside the base quote; Additional work needs its price. Explain Not required and Excluded items. Unknown and Excluded items prevent a complete-price ranking.
- Compare totals and the selected quote breakdown. Inspect the repair-cost chart, lowest-price intervals, sampled cost table and budget capacity. A quote that is cheaper before repairs may be more expensive after its allowance is exceeded.
- Download comparison CSV or Show copyable CSV to retain all inputs and exact results. Clarify missing scope and actual contract conditions before deciding which quote to accept.
The Formula
The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:
For a repair count n and quoted included allowance a, extra billable units = max(0,n−a). Extra decking cost = extra units × tax-inclusive price per extra unit. Fixed known cost = base quote + amounts for scope items marked Additional. Included items are already in the base and are not added again.
Known subtotal = fixed known cost + extra decking cost. All money is parsed to integer cents. Reserve = ceil(subtotal cents × entered reserve percentage / 100), rounded upward to a whole cent. Budget total = subtotal + reserve; headroom = available budget − budget total. The reserve is a planning buffer, not a quoted charge or a tax calculation. Prices must already include their applicable taxes.
Scope readiness requires all six listed items to be Included, Additional with a price, or Not required with an explanation. Unknown or Excluded scope leaves the quote incomplete. Its known costs remain visible, but it receives neither a complete-price ranking nor an asserted affordable repair limit. This check does not verify that two systems or contracts are actually equivalent.
Every integer repair count from zero through the entered maximum is considered. The lowest priced scope-ready quotes, including all exact ties, form inclusive ranking intervals. A single shared nonnegative reserve percentage preserves exact cent-price ordering. The sample plot includes evenly distributed whole-unit samples plus current count, allowance transitions, ranking boundaries and budget boundaries. Lines between markers are visual guides, not fractional-repair prices.
For budget B in cents and reserve basis points p, a subtotal S fits exactly when S ≤ floor(B×10000/(10000+p)). If fixed cost already exceeds that bound, no modeled count fits. Otherwise the maximum billable extra count is floor((bound−fixed)/unit price), plus the included allowance, limited to the comparison horizon. A zero extra-unit price leaves costs constant. If every count through the horizon fits, the result says all modeled counts fit rather than claiming a universal maximum.
The comparison accepts 1–4 quotes; whole repair counts and included units from 0–10000; base, additional scope and budget amounts from 0–1000000000; extra-unit price from 0–1000000; and reserve from 0–100%. Money and percentage inputs accept at most two decimal places. Currency selection labels prices without exchange conversion. A shared billing-unit description is required so that a panel or repair unit means the same work in every quote. No panel yield, damage probability, roof geometry, market price, financing, insurance entitlement, tax eligibility or structural adequacy is inferred.Worked Example
If you input:
- Current / maximum repair units: 12 / 40
- Shared repair unit: One matching 4 × 8 ft plywood panel, removal and installed replacement
- Budget / reserve: USD 13000 / 5%
- Quote A: USD 10000 base, zero included repairs, USD 150 per extra unit
- Quote B: USD 11000 base, 10 included repairs, USD 80 per extra unit
- Scope: All six listed items included in both base prices; illustrative assumptions
Result:
At 12 repairs, Quote A has USD 1800 in extra decking work: subtotal USD 11800, reserve USD 590 and budget total USD 12390. Quote B bills only two extra units, USD 160: subtotal USD 11160, reserve USD 558 and budget total USD 11718. A is cheaper at 0–6 repair units; B is cheaper at 7–40. With the USD 13000 budget, A fits through 15 repairs and B through 27; the next unit exceeds the budget in each case. These comparisons do not assess installation quality or contract equivalence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does this estimate the price of a new roof in my postcode?
No. Enter actual quotes or explicitly chosen planning prices. Location, access, roof complexity, products and installation conditions affect pricing. This calculator compares the prices and allowances you supply; it does not retrieve market averages or generate a contractor offer.
Why is the cheapest-looking quote excluded from the ranking?
Unknown or excluded work means the full cost is unresolved. Its displayed number is a known-cost lower bound, including your selected reserve, rather than a complete project price. Clarify that work or enter its additional price before using a complete-price comparison.
What does one decking repair unit mean?
It is the common billing unit you specify for all quotes, such as removal and installed replacement of one matching panel. Panel sizes, thicknesses and work scope must agree. The calculator does not convert damaged area into sheets, optimize cuts or decide what decking needs replacement.
Is the budget reserve charged by the contractor?
No. It is an additional planning buffer applied to known costs and shown separately. The quoted subtotal remains visible. Do not enter a reserve to stand in for an actual missing scope price; incomplete work still prevents a complete-price ranking.
Can a quote with more included repairs become cheaper later?
Yes. A higher base price may include more repair units or a lower extra-unit rate. The chart and inclusive price intervals reveal the exact whole-unit counts where the ordering changes, retaining every tie. The result concerns entered price only, not contractor quality.
What does all modeled counts fit mean?
It means the quote stays within budget for every whole repair count through your chosen maximum. The calculator has not established that unlimited repairs fit. Increase the maximum to explore further, within the supported software bounds.
Are taxes, insurance and financing included?
Prices are entered tax-inclusive; the tool neither chooses a tax rate nor determines tax eligibility. Insurance payments, deductibles, financing interest and structural repairs outside the supplied scope are not modeled. A complete price comparison still needs review of actual contract terms.
Similar Calculators
Roof Area Calculator
Plan shed, gable and hip roof area, faces and edges. Compare roofing, underlayment, starter and cap quantities with exact whole-pack purchasing, diagrams and CSV.
Roof Ventilation & Attic NFA Planner
Compare whole intake and exhaust vent quantities, net free area balance, available installation length and material cost with visual purchase choices and area scenarios.
Gutter Sizing & Rainfall Capacity Calculator
Compare gutter and downpipe ratings against roof rainfall demand, outlet layout and available fall. Explore capacity headroom, product alternatives, rainfall plots and CSV.
Chimney Masonry Joint Scope & Repair Quote Planner
Compare chimney repair quotes against measured mortar joints. Map repointing gaps and review separate crown, flashing and access charges.
