HVAC Replacement & Operating Cost Planner
Compare keeping an existing HVAC system with up to three replacement offers using your actual quotes and energy assumptions. Start with equipment, installation, other costs and upfront rebates; optionally add annual delivered heating and cooling, gas efficiency or seasonal electric COP, resistance backup, tariffs, maintenance and future repairs. See cost breakdowns, separate electricity and gas quantities, cumulative cost or savings timelines, exact annual ledgers and a complete CSV. The first system is an explicit comparison baseline. The planner does not estimate equipment size, retrieve market prices, establish incentive eligibility or predict site performance. Examples are illustrative, and retaining existing equipment for the horizon is only as credible as your entered repair and replacement assumptions.
Compare the quote. Follow the costs.
Put installation, energy and future repairs on one timeline. See when lower running costs recover an upfront difference—and when they do not.
Heat pump: USD 6,500 upfront, USD 17,200.47 present cost over 15 years.
Edit quotes, energy and future costs
Compare entered offers for the same heating and cooling service. Examples are illustrative. This planner does not size equipment, infer climate or predict actual bills. Rebate amounts are your assumptions, not eligibility determinations.
System offers and future costs
Your system comparison
Lowest modeled present cost: Keep existing system. This is a cost comparison, not a recommendation about equipment capacity, comfort, installation quality or reliability.
Cost recovery against Keep existing system
First nonnegative savings may reverse after later costs. Sustained recovery means savings stay nonnegative through this entered horizon only. Year 0 means the option already starts no more expensive; it is not an energy-savings payback promise. Baseline compared with itself is always zero.
- First nominal recovery
- Not reached
- Sustained nominal recovery
- Not reached
- First discounted recovery
- Not reached
- Sustained discounted recovery
- Not reached
Where the money goes
Shared 0–USD 20,815.91 nominal-cost scale through year 15. Solid = net upfront; diagonal = electricity; vertical = gas; horizontal = maintenance; fine reverse diagonal = dated events. Values below each bar do not depend on color.
Keep existing system · USD 19,087.61
- upfront: USD 0
- electricity: USD 2,490.25
- gas: USD 13,138.67
- maintenance: USD 3,458.68
- events: USD 0
New furnace and AC · USD 20,815.91
- upfront: USD 6,000
- electricity: USD 1,694.75
- gas: USD 11,391.81
- maintenance: USD 1,729.34
- events: USD 0
Heat pump · USD 20,092.63
- upfront: USD 6,500
- electricity: USD 10,998.61
- gas: USD 0
- maintenance: USD 2,594.01
- events: USD 0
Follow cost and recovery over time
Lower cumulative cost means less modeled spending. Lines connect year-end checkpoints; they do not imply continuous payments or within-year payback. Exact annual values are in the selected system ledger below.
- Keep existing system (solid): year 15 USD 19,087.61.
- New furnace and AC (long dash): year 15 USD 20,815.91.
- Heat pump (dots): year 15 USD 20,092.63.
Annual energy behind the costs
Electricity and gas use separate scales and units. These quantities stay constant across the years; only entered prices change. Gas fixed charges may remain even where modeled gas use is zero.
Keep existing system
Electricity: 1,200 kWh/year (shared 0–5,300 kWh scale).
Heating 0 + cooling 1,000 + additional auxiliary 200 kWh/year.
Gas: 426.5 therms/year (shared 0–426.5 therm scale).
New furnace and AC
Electricity: 816.67 kWh/year (shared 0–5,300 kWh scale).
Heating 0 + cooling 666.67 + additional auxiliary 150 kWh/year.
Gas: 359.16 therms/year (shared 0–426.5 therm scale).
Heat pump
Electricity: 5,300 kWh/year (shared 0–5,300 kWh scale).
Heating 4,600 + cooling 600 + additional auxiliary 100 kWh/year.
Gas: 0 therms/year (shared 0–426.5 therm scale).
Exact system comparison
All costs use USD. Fractions preserve calculation precision, not forecast certainty.
| System | Gross quote | Net upfront | Nominal horizon cost | Present horizon cost | Nominal savings | Discounted savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep existing system | 0 | 0 | 9320121543585401301984325633/488281250000000000000000 | 23410435764783586842230220579154625/1557967416600764580522382952407 | 0 | 0 |
| New furnace and AC | 6000 | 6000 | 120697705249636558546829474889/5798339843750000000000000 | 522863165111193596261384979869962200/29601380915414527029925276095733 | -80170095356479344686124863977/46386718750000000000000000 | -78064885580305446259010788866024325/29601380915414527029925276095733 |
| Heat pump | 11500 | 6500 | 6131782744182828665549082643/305175781250000000000000 | 26797775760448479859912321240670900/1557967416600764580522382952407 | -2453654235535622814471032979/2441406250000000000000000 | -3387339995664893017682100661516275/1557967416600764580522382952407 |
Exact annual ledger · Heat pump
Year 0 records the net quote. Later amounts occur at year end. Event costs are already future nominal values; they are not escalated again. Select another system above to inspect its complete ledger.
| Year | Electricity | Gas | Maintenance | Events | Cash flow | Discounted flow | Cumulative cost | Present cost | Nominal savings | Discounted savings | Event names |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6500 | 6500 | 6500 | 6500 | -6500 | -6500 | — |
| 1 | 636 | 0 | 150 | 0 | 786 | 78600/103 | 7286 | 748100/103 | -24729/4 | -637725/103 | — |
| 2 | 16218/25 | 0 | 153 | 0 | 20043/25 | 8017200/10609 | 202193/25 | 85071500/10609 | -1171629/200 | -62444625/10609 | — |
| 3 | 413559/625 | 0 | 7803/50 | 0 | 1022193/1250 | 817754400/1092727 | 11131843/1250 | 9580118900/1092727 | -55275579/10000 | -6101209275/1092727 | — |
| 4 | 21091509/31250 | 0 | 397953/2500 | 0 | 52131843/62500 | 83410948800/112550881 | 608723993/62500 | 1070163195500/112550881 | -2595179529/500000 | -594704671125/112550881 | — |
| 5 | 1075666959/1562500 | 0 | 20295603/125000 | 0 | 2658723993/3125000 | 8507916777600/11592740743 | 33094923643/3125000 | 118734725914100/11592740743 | -121160405979/25000000 | -57815152937475/11592740743 | — |
| 6 | 54859014909/78125000 | 0 | 1035075753/6250000 | 0 | 135594923643/156250000 | 867807511315200/1194052296529 | 1790341105793/156250000 | 13097484280467500/1194052296529 | -5619493204929/1250000000 | -5604139077343125/1194052296529 | — |
| 7 | 2797809760359/3906250000 | 0 | 52788863403/312500000 | 0 | 6915341105793/7812500000 | 88516366154150400/122987386542487 | 96432396395443/7812500000 | 1437557247042302900/122987386542487 | -258609778451379/62500000000 | -541442514094228275/122987386542487 | — |
| 8 | 142688297778309/195312500000 | 0 | 2692232033553/15625000000 | 0 | 352682396395443/390625000000 | 9028669347723340800/12667700813876161 | 5174302216167593/390625000000 | 157097065793080539500/12667700813876161 | -11789879951020329/3125000000000 | -52118630242749925125/12667700813876161 | — |
| 9 | 7277103186693759/9765625000000 | 0 | 137303833711203/781250000000 | 0 | 17986802216167593/19531250000000 | 920924273467780761600/1304773183829244583 | 276701913024547243/19531250000000 | 17101922050155076330100/1304773183829244583 | -531322940002036779/156250000000000 | -4995924146689772393475/1304773183829244583 | — |
| 10 | 371132262521381709/488281250000000 | 0 | 7002495519271353/39062500000000 | 0 | 917326913024547243/976562500000000 | 93934275893713637683200/134391637934412192049 | 14752422564251909393/976562500000000 | 1855432247059686499683500/134391637934412192049 | -23599423065103875729/7812500000000000 | -476606120741072627299125/134391637934412192049 | — |
| 11 | 18927745388590467159/24414062500000000 | 0 | 357127271482839003/1953125000000000 | 0 | 46783672564251909393/48828125000000000 | 9581296141158791043686400/13842338707244455781047 | 784404800776847379043/48828125000000000 | 200690817588306500511086900/13842338707244455781047 | -1028668232570297662179/390625000000000000 | -45217075666797139830472275/13842338707244455781047 | — |
| 12 | 965315014818113825109/1220703125000000000 | 0 | 18213490845624789153/97656250000000000 | 0 | 2385967300776847379043/2441406250000000000 | 977292206398196686456012800/1425760886846178945447841 | 41606207339619216331193/2441406250000000000 | 21648446417993766239097963500/1425760886846178945447841 | -43716962673585180771129/19531250000000000000 | -4262276607187704642842209125/1425760886846178945447841 | — |
| 13 | 49231065755723805080559/61035156250000000000 | 0 | 928888033126864246803/4882812500000000000 | 0 | 121684332339619216331193/122070312500000000000 | 99683805052616062018513305600/146853371345156431381127623 | 2201994699320580032890843/122070312500000000000 | 2329473786105973984645603546100/146853371345156431381127623 | -1792309236977844219327579/976562500000000000000 | -398716107518108700723711149475/146853371345156431381127623 | — |
| 14 | 2510784353541914059108509/3051757812500000000000 | 0 | 47373289689470076586953/244140625000000000000 | 0 | 6205900949320580032890843/6103515625000000000000 | 10167748115366838325888357171200/15125897248551112432256145169 | 116305635915349581677432993/6103515625000000000000 | 250103548084282158744385522419500/15125897248551112432256145169 | -69544978117120055185706529/48828125000000000000000 | -36957324006098258670660536575125/15125897248551112432256145169 | — |
| 15 | 128050002030637617014533959/152587890625000000000000 | 0 | 2416037774162973905934603/12207031250000000000000 | 0 | 316500948415349581677432993/305175781250000000000000 | 1037110307767417509240612431462400/1557967416600764580522382952407 | 6131782744182828665549082643/305175781250000000000000 | 26797775760448479859912321240670900/1557967416600764580522382952407 | -2453654235535622814471032979/2441406250000000000000000 | -3387339995664893017682100661516275/1557967416600764580522382952407 | — |
Save the complete comparison
CSV includes all inputs, every system and year, cost and energy breakdowns, both timeline measures and calculation assumptions. The selected view does not limit the export.
How to use this calculator
- Open Edit quotes, energy and future costs. Choose Quotes only or Quotes and operating costs, name the currency, and explicitly select the system that will be the comparison baseline.
- For each system enter equipment, installation labor, other upfront costs and a rebate or discount. Include taxes or enabling work in other costs if not already included, and avoid assuming an incentive is guaranteed.
- In lifecycle mode enter annual delivered heating and cooling energy, the comparison horizon, year-one tariffs, annual price changes and discount rate. Do not enter equipment capacity in place of annual energy.
- Enter each system’s heating technology and AFUE or seasonal compressor COP, resistance-backup share where applicable, seasonal cooling ratio, additional auxiliary electricity, retained gas charges and annual maintenance. Add dated repairs or replacements at their future nominal cost.
- Inspect a system’s costs, recovery years and annual ledger. Switch the timeline between cost and savings and between nominal and discounted amounts. Download HVAC CSV or Show CSV text to retain every system, input and result.
The Formula
The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:
Net upfront cost = equipment + installation labor + other upfront costs − entered rebate. Rebate cannot exceed the gross quote. Quotes-only mode uses these amounts and ignores retained energy and future-cost drafts.
Lifecycle mode uses the same entered annual delivered heating H and cooling C, in million Btu, for every system. Gas heating therms/year = H × 10 / (AFUE / 100). Electric heating kWh/year = H × 1000000 / 3412 × [(1 − b) / COP + b], where b is the fraction of useful heating supplied by resistance backup at COP 1. The compressor COP excludes that backup. Cooling kWh/year = C × 1000 / entered seasonal cooling ratio in Btu/Wh. Total electricity adds separately entered auxiliary kWh. Planning conversions are 1 therm = 100000 Btu and the rounded EIA teaching factor 1 kWh = 3412 Btu. No automatic SEER-to-SEER2 conversion is made; ratings and an assumed seasonal COP do not establish local performance.
Year y electricity cost = annual kWh × year-one electricity price × (1 + electricity escalation/100)^(y−1). Gas cost = (annual therms × year-one gas price + retained annual fixed gas charges) × (1 + gas escalation/100)^(y−1). Maintenance escalates separately. Add events entered for year y at their stated future nominal amount, without further escalation. Same-year events are summed. Fixed gas charges remain for an electric option when entered.
Year 0 is net upfront cost. For years 1 through the horizon, costs occur at year end. Discounted cash flow = annual cash flow / (1 + discount rate/100)^y. Nominal and present totals sum the respective flows. Savings = baseline cumulative cost − candidate cumulative cost. Positive savings indicate a lower modeled cost. First nonnegative year and the first year remaining nonnegative through the entire entered horizon are reported separately, include year 0 and use no within-year interpolation. Recovery can reverse after a repair. All tied lowest costs remain identified.
Limits: 1–4 systems, 1–30 whole years, 0–10 dated costs per system. Each quote component, rebate, annual maintenance, fixed gas charge and dated cost is 0–1000000000 in one currency; auxiliary electricity is 0–1000000000 kWh/year. Annual loads are 0–1000000 million Btu; prices are 0–1000 currency/kWh or currency/therm. AFUE is positive through 100%, compressor COP positive through 10, cooling ratio positive through 100 Btu/Wh, and backup 0–100%. Annual price changes range from −20% to 50%, discount from 0% to 50%. Decimals accept at most six places. Exact rational arithmetic retains calculation precision, not forecast certainty.
No equipment sizing, hourly weather response, duct losses beyond your assumptions, financing, tax benefit eligibility, automatic service life, residual value or future tariff is inferred. A dated replacement adds a cost but does not automatically change efficiency or annual service. Include appropriate future costs for an existing system; a zero quote alone does not mean it can operate indefinitely.Method sources
Worked Example
If you input:
- Mode and horizon: Operating costs; USD; 15 years; keep-existing system as baseline
- Annual loads and tariffs: 34.12 million Btu heating; 12 million Btu cooling; USD 0.12/kWh; USD 1.50/therm
- Escalation and discount: 2% annual electricity, gas and maintenance changes; 3% discount rate
- Existing system: Zero upfront; gas AFUE 80%; cooling ratio 12 Btu/Wh; 200 auxiliary kWh/year; USD 120 annual fixed gas charge; USD 200 annual maintenance
- New furnace and AC: USD 4000 equipment + 1500 labor + 500 other; no rebate; AFUE 95%; cooling ratio 18; 150 auxiliary kWh; USD 120 fixed gas and USD 100 maintenance per year
- Heat pump: USD 8000 equipment + 3000 labor + 500 other − 5000 rebate; compressor COP 2.5; resistance supplies 10% of heating; cooling ratio 20; 100 auxiliary kWh; zero fixed gas and USD 150 maintenance per year
- Future events: None entered; this is an explicit scenario, not an equipment-life prediction
Result:
The heat-pump net quote is USD 6500. Its annual heating electricity is 4600 kWh; cooling uses 600 kWh and auxiliary electricity 100 kWh. At USD 0.12/kWh, electricity costs USD 636 in year one; with USD 150 maintenance, year-one operating cost is USD 786. The existing system uses 426.5 therms and has year-one cost USD 1103.75. Over 15 years, the heat pump totals about USD 20092.63 nominal or USD 17200.47 discounted. The baseline discounted total is about USD 15026.27, so heat-pump discounted savings are negative: about −USD 2174.20. Neither nominal nor discounted recovery is reached within this horizon. This scenario assumes no future repair or replacement events; it does not prove the existing system will last 15 years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does this estimate local HVAC installation prices?
No. Enter actual quotes or clearly labeled assumptions. The planner separates equipment, labor, other costs and an entered upfront rebate; it does not infer prices from home size, location or tonnage.
Can I compare quotes without energy information?
Yes. Quotes-only mode compares net upfront costs while preserving inactive energy and future-cost drafts. Switch to lifecycle mode when you have suitable annual-load, efficiency and price assumptions; required blanks then invalidate dependent results.
How is annual heating energy different from heating capacity?
Annual delivered energy is the total useful heat supplied over a year, measured here in million Btu. Equipment capacity is a rate such as Btu per hour. This planner does not convert design capacity into annual demand or size equipment.
What should I enter for COP and resistance backup?
Enter an assumed seasonal compressor heat-output-to-electric-input ratio, excluding backup. The backup field is the share of useful heating supplied by resistance at COP 1, not hours of operation. A test-point COP or a ratio already including backup must not be used without reconciling those definitions.
Does the cooling ratio convert SEER to SEER2?
No. It uses the supplied seasonal Btu/Wh ratio as a planning assumption. SEER and SEER2 use different test procedures, and neither guarantees actual site efficiency. Supply a defensible basis and do not double-count electricity already represented by an efficiency ratio.
Why are first recovery and sustained recovery different?
An option may first cost no more than the baseline, then become more expensive after a later repair. Sustained recovery requires nonnegative savings for every remaining modeled year. Both are evaluated only at annual checkpoints; year 0 means the upfront amount is already no greater, not a guaranteed energy payback.
Will keeping the old system always look cheapest?
It can if its quote is zero and no future failures or replacement costs are entered. The planner does not invent a remaining lifespan. Enter appropriate maintenance and dated costs; a replacement event adds cost but does not change operating efficiency automatically.
Are rebates, future bills and discounted savings guaranteed?
No. Rebates are entered assumptions at year zero, not eligibility checks. Loads, efficiencies, prices, escalation and future costs may differ from reality. The comparison excludes financing, tax effects, residual value and unentered costs. Review affordability, product suitability and installation quality separately.
Similar Calculators
Room Heat Loss & Retrofit Calculator
Explore room heat loss and sensible cooling, compare envelope and ventilation retrofits, and visualize heat flows and outdoor-temperature sensitivity with exact CSV ledgers.
Electricity Cost Calculator
Estimate appliance electricity cost from wattage, daily use, electricity rate, and billing fees.
Window Replacement Cost & Quote Calculator
Compare window replacement quotes by opening, installation, allowances and rebates. Explore optional heating savings, payback and net present value with charts and CSV.
