Traditional vs Roth 401(k) Calculator & Match Planner
A traditional 401(k) election can buy more employee contributions with the same paycheck cost. A qualified withdrawal from a designated Roth account can leave more of each invested dollar available later. Compare both options for one contribution year, with an annual employer match and identical take-home budgets. The planner shows where today’s dollars go, how a contribution cap changes the comparison, and the future tax rate at which the modeled outcomes meet. Use the ledger and CSV to check the assumptions before changing an election with payroll.
Compare both elections on the same take-home budget
Model one year of employee contributions and employer matching. See what each election could provide at a future qualified withdrawal, with today’s budget held fixed.
Pay, match and tax assumptions
Regular employee limit is $24,500.00 before pay or plan constraints.
Use eligible compensation from this employer. The annual IRS match-pay limit applies automatically.
How much lower can take-home pay be this year? Both elections use this same budget.
Enter your assumed income tax saved per traditional dollar. Leave payroll taxes out of this rate.
Employer cents per eligible dollar. For a 50¢ match, enter 50%.
For a match on the first 6% of eligible pay, enter 6%. Use 0% when there is no match.
Use a year-end horizon when the Roth withdrawal would be qualified. This model assumes age 59½ or older then.
Applies equally to invested plan money. Budget cash left over earns zero in this comparison.
Assumed effective rate applied to the pretax plan money compared here.
Use one employer with the same annual match for Traditional and Roth, a pretax match and full vesting. Use your plan’s confirmed annual formula or true-up. The planner covers regular contributions and assumes your modeled Roth withdrawal qualifies.
Traditional finishes $1,447.03 ahead
At 20% future tax · year-end 2046
- Traditional
- $28,940.57
- Roth
- $27,493.54
Where this year’s dollars go
Employee and employer money reaching the plan. Any unused take-home budget stays outside it as cash.
Traditional
- Employee
- $12,000.00
- Employer
- $3,000.00
Roth
- Employee
- $9,000.00
- Employer
- $3,000.00
After-tax value by future tax rate
Retirement money after modeled income tax plus any unspent budget cash. The dotted marker shows your entered tax rate.
- Traditional · solid
- Roth · dashed
Break-even near 25% future tax
Compare the calculation details
The ledger shows payroll cost, plan funding, future taxes and cash. A separate table contains the chart’s tax checkpoints.
Open calculation ledger and tax sensitivity
| Metric | Traditional | Roth |
|---|---|---|
| Take-home used | $9,000.00 | $9,000.00 |
| Current income tax saved | $3,000.00 | $0.00 |
| Budget held as cash | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Employee contribution | $12,000.00 | $9,000.00 |
| Employer match | $3,000.00 | $3,000.00 |
| Remaining available match | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Extra take-home budget to reach match threshold | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Pretax plan funding | $15,000.00 | $3,000.00 |
| Designated Roth plan funding | $0.00 | $9,000.00 |
| Pretax plan money at horizon | $36,175.71 | $7,235.14 |
| Designated Roth money at horizon | $0.00 | $21,705.43 |
| Modeled future income tax | $7,235.14 | $1,447.03 |
| After-tax plan money | $28,940.57 | $27,493.54 |
| After-tax money plus budget cash | $28,940.57 | $27,493.54 |
| Future tax | Traditional | Roth |
|---|---|---|
| 0% | $36,175.71 | $28,940.57 |
| 10% | $32,558.14 | $28,217.06 |
| 20% · selected | $28,940.57 | $27,493.54 |
| 25% | $27,131.78 | $27,131.78 |
| 30% | $25,323.00 | $26,770.03 |
| 40% | $21,705.43 | $26,046.51 |
| 50% | $18,087.85 | $25,323.00 |
| 60% | $14,470.28 | $24,599.49 |
| 70% | $10,852.71 | $23,875.97 |
| 80% | $7,235.14 | $23,152.46 |
| 90% | $3,617.57 | $22,428.94 |
| 100% | $0.00 | $21,705.43 |
Open selectable CSV
How to use this calculator
- Choose Contribution year and enter Eligible annual pay from the plan. The annual IRS pay ceiling for matching is applied separately.
- Enter Annual take-home budget and Current marginal income tax. Use the total cash reduction you can sustain for this contribution year.
- Use your confirmed annual Employer match rate and Match applies through percentage. For a 50-cent match on up to 6% of pay, enter 50% and 6%. Use 0% if the plan has no match.
- Set Years after contribution year, Annual growth assumption and Future tax on pretax money. Choose a future year at which your withdrawal would qualify for Roth treatment.
- Read the two after-tax values and the crossover. Check the payroll cost, remaining available match and unspent cash in the ledger or download the comparison CSV.
The Formula
The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:
The 2026 regular elective deferral limit is USD 24,500, the annual additions dollar limit is USD 72,000, and the compensation ceiling for matching is USD 360,000. The 2027 limits are USD 25,500, USD 75,000 and USD 375,000. Traditional and designated Roth employee contributions share one regular elective limit. Employer contributions count toward annual additions. Annual additions can also be limited by 100% of compensation. The model uses one employer, one regular election in each comparison and no other contributions.
Treat each entered USD amount as whole cents and each tax or match percentage as whole basis points. Traditional employee dollars cost employee contributions times (1 − current marginal income tax rate). Roth employee dollars cost the full contribution. Both kinds of employee contributions are subject to Social Security and Medicare taxation, so payroll taxes are excluded from the model’s rate difference. Use a single assumed incremental rate per dollar and avoid assuming it applies across brackets or benefit cliffs.
Recognized match pay is the lesser of eligible compensation and the IRS compensation ceiling. The confirmed annual match formula is match rate × min(employee contribution, recognized match pay × match-through percentage). Round the match to the nearest cent, half up. Choose the largest whole-cent employee contribution that stays within the exact take-home cost before rounding, the regular elective limit, eligible pay and the combined employee plus calculated match limit. This models preserving the annual match formula when the combined limit constrains contributions. Actual plan terms and payroll corrections govern how limits are enforced. Match shown as available is the largest modeled match within those same limits. The extra budget to reach the match threshold uses the lesser of the rounded-up annual threshold and the maximum modeled employee deferral.
Round the displayed take-home cost to cents, half up. The difference between the original budget and that cost stays as cash with zero growth. All modeled funding occurs at the end of the contribution year. Grow each plan’s pretax and designated Roth balances at (1 + annual growth rate) raised to the number of years, then round each resulting bucket to cents. Apply the selected future effective income tax rate to the pretax balance and round the tax to cents, half up. Add the after-tax plan balance to budget cash. The crossover compares straight lines using those rounded plan buckets before rounding individual tax amounts, so values near it can tie to the cent. The sensitivity ledger uses the same tax rounding as the selected result.
Use 2026 or 2027, USD 0.01–10 million of pay, a USD 0–10 million budget, current marginal income tax 0–75%, modeled future effective income tax and match percentages 0–100%, 5–60 whole years and annual growth between −20% and 20%. Currency and percentages accept two decimal places. The comparison assumes a future qualified designated Roth distribution, a vested pretax employer match, and one contribution year. It excludes catch-up, employer Roth contributions, other employer funding, multiple employers, pay-period matching without a true-up, plan-specific pay restrictions, fees, inflation, individual tax credits and filing calculations, and nonqualified distributions. Future rates and returns are assumptions you supply.Method sources
- IRS Notice 2025-67: 2026 retirement plan limits
- IRS Notice 2026-66: 2027 retirement plan limits
- IRS: 401(k) deferrals and payroll tax treatment
- IRS: 401(k) elective deferral and combined contribution limits
- IRS: matching with compensation above the annual limit
- IRS 2026 Form 1099-R instructions: qualified designated Roth distributions
- IRS Notice 2024-2 Section L: designated Roth employer contributions
Worked Example
If you input:
- Contribution year: 2026
- Eligible annual pay: USD 100,000
- Annual take-home budget: USD 9,000
- Current marginal income tax: 25%
- Employer match rate and match through: 50% on the first 6% of eligible pay
- Years after contribution year: 20
- Annual growth assumption: 4.5%
- Future tax on pretax money: 20%
Result:
The USD 9,000 take-home budget funds USD 12,000 Traditional or USD 9,000 Roth employee contributions. Both receive USD 3,000 of pretax employer match. At the selected future tax rate, the modeled Traditional value is USD 28,940.57 and the Roth value is USD 27,493.54, a USD 1,447.03 Traditional advantage. They are approximately even at a 25% future tax rate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the two paycheck costs the same?
Both options start with the same take-home budget. Each uses as much as its modeled contribution limits allow at the entered current tax rate. Any unused cash remains visible and is included in the final comparison at zero growth.
What makes a Roth 401(k) withdrawal qualified?
In the age-based scenario, the distribution is after age 59½ and after the five-tax-year period that begins in the year of the first contribution to the designated Roth account. Other qualifying events and rollovers can affect treatment. This calculator assumes you will meet the conditions at the selected horizon.
How is employer matching treated in a Roth election?
Here the entered annual matching formula applies equally to both elections and the employer money is vested and pretax. Plans can offer designated Roth employer contributions. Use this comparison when your employer match is deposited into a pretax account.
What if I receive an employer match each paycheck?
Use the annual formula when payroll confirms that a year-end true-up can produce the entered annual match. Plans with per-paycheck matching and no true-up can pay a different match if contributions reach the cap partway through the year.
What does the future tax break-even mean?
It is the rate that would make the two after-tax amounts equal under the other assumptions entered. Differences in contributions, match and unused cash can move the crossover. Some inputs yield a tie at every tax rate or one election that leads throughout the range.
Can I contribute the year’s employee limit to both options?
The statutory regular limit is shared by Traditional and Roth employee deferrals. The alternatives each use the same available regular limit for a hypothetical one-year election. Catch-up contributions and coordination with other plans or balances are outside this comparison.
Does a larger projected balance mean I should change my election?
The result depends on your plan’s match rules, current tax saved per contribution dollar, future taxes and investment return. Test several plausible assumptions and confirm eligibility and payroll procedures before making a change.
Similar Calculators
TSP Contribution & Matching Calculator
Plan 2026 or 2027 TSP contributions by paycheck. Compare early max-out, paced savings and filling your allowance, including FERS matching and catch-up limits.
Roth IRA Conversion Calculator & 2026 Federal Tax Planner
Compare the 2026 federal tax from two Roth IRA conversion amounts. Estimate the Form 8606 taxable portion, remaining IRA basis, and room in a tax bracket.
Retirement Savings Target Calculator
Retirement Savings Target for the exact fields in this tool, with clear inputs and an immediate result for planning or comparison.
Early 401(k) Withdrawal Calculator
Estimate cash after federal withholding and tax on a pre-tax 401(k) withdrawal. Solve for a cash target and compare future retirement balances.
401(k) Loan Comparison Calculator
Compare a 401(k) loan with an outside loan using monthly payments, cash fees, investment scenarios and complete repayment and account ledgers.
