Tax-Equivalent Yield Comparison Planner

Compare up to six hypothetical income alternatives on a common simple annual basis. Enter gross income yields, the share assumed untaxed and additional annual fees, then inspect net income and the tax rates where alternatives trade places. Exact crossover intervals preserve ties and reveal alternatives that never have the highest modeled yield. This is an effective-tax assumption model, not a tax-status lookup or an assessment of investment suitability.

Tax-equivalent yield planner

Compare the income you keep

See how tax assumptions and fees change annual income—and exactly where alternatives trade places.

One effective tax rate applies to each alternative’s nonexempt income share. No tax status is inferred. Compare like-for-like simple annual gross income yields; risk, market-price changes and compounding are outside this model.

Highest modeled net yield
3.6%
Fully exempt assumption
Entered tax assumption
32%
Applied only to the nonexempt income share
Selected net income (USD)
3400
Taxable income

Highest modeled yield is an arithmetic comparison, not investment suitability. “≈” marks rounded displays; exact fractions remain in the tables’ details and export. At zero principal, income is zero while rate comparisons still apply.

Tax-rate sensitivity

Horizontal axis: effective tax rate, 0–100%. Vertical axis: net annual yield after tax and fees. Line styles and numbers identify alternatives. Diamonds mark pairwise crossings; a crossing is not necessarily an overall lead change.

Net annual income yields across effective tax rates from zero through one hundred percent, including negative values and pairwise crossings.1. Taxable income: 5% at 0% tax; 0% at 100% tax.Taxable income: 3.4% at the entered tax rate.2. Fully exempt assumption: 3.6% at 0% tax; 3.6% at 100% tax.Fully exempt assumption: 3.6% at the entered tax rate.3. Partly exempt with fee: 4.2% at 0% tax; 2% at 100% tax.Partly exempt with fee: 3.496% at the entered tax rate.Taxable income and Fully exempt assumption cross at exactly 28% tax and 18/5% net yield.Taxable income and Partly exempt with fee cross at exactly 200/7% tax and 25/7% net yield.Fully exempt assumption and Partly exempt with fee cross at exactly 300/11% tax and 18/5% net yield.

Entered tax rate: 32%. Plot range: -0.5% to 5.5% net yield. Very close lines or crossings may overlap; exact values are available below.

After-tax income comparison

AlternativeGross / tax / fee (USD)Net income (USD)Net yieldHypothetical taxable equivalentHighest-yield tax interval
1. Taxable income5000 / 1600 / 034003.4%5% gross benchmark yield0% through 28% tax, inclusive; ties are included.
2. Fully exempt assumptionHighest at entered rate3600 / 0 / 036003.6%≈ 5.2941% gross benchmark yield28% through 100% tax, inclusive; ties are included.
3. Partly exempt with fee4400 / 704 / 20034963.496%≈ 5.1412% gross benchmark yieldNever highest within 0–100% tax under these assumptions.

Income breakdown: Taxable income

Gross income = tax cost + fee cost + net income. These are separate bars on one signed scale, not stacked totals. A negative net bar extends left of zero.

Gross income5000 USD
Tax cost1600 USD
Fee cost0 USD
Net income3400 USD

Common scale across all alternatives: 0 to 5000 USD.

Exact selected values and interval
Gross income (USD)
5000
Tax cost (USD)
1600
Fee cost (USD)
0
Net income (USD)
3400
Exact net yield (%)
17/5
Exact highest-yield interval (%)
0 through 28, inclusive
Exact equivalent gross yield (%)
5

Pairwise crossover ledger

These compare two alternatives at a time. Read the highest-yield intervals above to find the leader among all alternatives.

PairRelationshipExact crossing tax rate (%)
Taxable income / Fully exempt assumptionWithin 0–100%28
Taxable income / Partly exempt with feeWithin 0–100%200/7
Fully exempt assumption / Partly exempt with feeWithin 0–100%300/11

Keep the complete comparison

CSV includes all inputs, exact income values, equivalent-yield states, intervals and pair comparisons. Import fractions as text. These assumptions do not establish tax eligibility or equal investment risk.

How to use this calculator

  1. Load Taxable vs exempt example or Fee-aware crossover example, then open Edit yields and assumptions. All example rates and products are hypothetical.
  2. Enter Starting principal, Currency label and Effective tax rate. This is one assumed rate on taxable income, not a tax-bracket or jurisdiction lookup. Set the hypothetical Fully taxable benchmark fee used for equivalent-yield comparisons.
  3. Name each alternative and enter a comparable Simple annual gross income yield, Income share assumed untaxed and Additional annual fee. Use actual tax treatment to choose suitable assumptions; labels do not determine eligibility. Copy or add up to six alternatives.
  4. Select Update comparison. Read net income and hypothetical taxable equivalent, including negative values or the explicit no-match/all-yields states at 100% tax.
  5. Select an alternative under Tax-rate sensitivity to inspect its signed income breakdown and exact values. Read highest-yield tax intervals to compare all alternatives; use the pairwise ledger for individual crossings and ties.
  6. Download yield CSV or use Show selectable CSV for complete exact results and assumptions. Import fractions as text. Compare risk, liquidity, maturity, tax circumstances and yield conventions separately before using the arithmetic in a decision.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

Use comparable simple annual gross income yields, not interchangeable coupon rates, SEC yields, APYs or YTMs. Let Y be gross yield in percentage points, E the income share assumed untaxed (%), F the annual fee (% of principal), t the effective tax rate (%) and P starting principal. Define A=Y−F and B=Y(1−E/100)/100. Net yield N(t)=A−Bt, in percentage points. Gross income=PY/100; tax cost=P(Y−N−F)/100; fee cost=PF/100; net income=PN/100. Gross equals tax plus fee plus net exactly. Fees are subtracted after tax and assumed nondeductible.
For a hypothetical fully taxable benchmark charging annual fee Fb, solve y(1−t/100)−Fb=N(t). For t<100, equivalent gross yield y=(N+Fb)/(1−t/100). With zero fees and a fully exempt alternative, this reduces to the standard exempt yield divided by one minus the tax rate. Equivalent yields may be negative when fees dominate income. They are mathematical comparison rates, not available product quotes.
At t=100, every benchmark gross yield nets −Fb. If N=−Fb, every benchmark yield matches. Otherwise none matches: the benchmark is always below or above the alternative. No division by zero or invented infinite yield is used.
For alternatives i and j with different slopes, their exact crossing tax rate is (Ai−Aj)/(Bi−Bj). Equal slopes with equal intercepts tie throughout; unequal intercepts never cross. Crossings outside 0–100% are retained but not plotted. A pairwise crossing need not be an overall lead change.
For each alternative intersect [0,100] with every inequality (Ai−Aj)−(Bi−Bj)t≥0. This analytically gives its highest-net-yield interval. Endpoints are inclusive, ties and singleton intervals are retained, and an empty interval means the alternative never leads under these assumptions. The chart does not locate intervals by sampling.
All decimals and calculations use reduced exact rational arithmetic. Monetary values are not rounded to cents in the model; rounded displays are marked approximate. At zero principal, monetary amounts are zero while rate comparisons remain meaningful.
Bounds: principal 0–1,000,000,000,000 with at most two decimals; tax rate, benchmark fee and each gross yield, untaxed share and annual fee 0–100% with up to four decimals; one to six alternatives; names up to 80 characters; three uppercase currency letters. Blank values and malformed numbers are not silently replaced.
One common effective tax rate applies only to each entered nonexempt income share. No federal/state/local tax-base combination, NIIT, AMT, deduction, credit, municipal-security qualification, market discount, price change, default, duration, liquidity, reinvestment or compounding is inferred. If a quoted yield already includes fees, enter only additional fees. Highest modeled yield does not mean best investment.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Principal and tax: USD 100,000; effective tax assumption 32%; benchmark fee 0%.
  • Alternatives: 5% fully taxable with no fee; 3.6% fully exempt with no fee; 4.4% gross with 50% untaxed income and a 0.2% annual fee.

Result:

At 32% tax, the taxable alternative nets 5% × (1−0.32)=3.4%, or USD 3,400. The exempt assumption nets 3.6%, or USD 3,600. The partial alternative nets 4.4% × (1−0.5×0.32)−0.2%=3.496%, or USD 3,496. The exempt alternative’s fully taxable equivalent is 3.6%/0.68=90/17%, approximately 5.2941%. The taxable and exempt lines tie at 28% tax. Taxable has the highest modeled yield from 0–28%, exempt from 28–100%, with both included at the tie. The partial alternative never leads both, despite crossing each separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does tax-equivalent yield compare?

It is the hypothetical gross yield a fully taxable alternative would need to match the modeled net income yield, including the entered benchmark fee. With a fully exempt yield and zero fees, the familiar formula is exempt yield divided by one minus the tax rate. This equalizes modeled income, not credit risk, liquidity or maturity.

Can I enter a municipal bond and let the tool determine its taxes?

No. Municipal interest is not universally exempt, state rules differ and AMT or other provisions may apply. The tool does not classify a security or combine different tax bases. You supply one effective tax rate and the income share assumed wholly untaxed; check whether that simplification fits your circumstances.

Can I compare coupon rate, APY, SEC yield and YTM directly?

No. Those measures have different definitions and can include different timing, compounding, prices or fees. Use comparable simple annual gross income assumptions. The bond-yield and CD calculators address different yield and compounding workflows; this tool does not convert them automatically.

Why can a pairwise crossing fail to change the overall leader?

Two alternatives can become equal while a third remains above both. The pairwise ledger lists every crossing; the highest-yield intervals solve against all alternatives simultaneously. In the default example, the partly exempt option crosses both peers but never has the highest modeled yield.

How do annual fees affect the comparison?

Each alternative’s fee is a percentage of starting principal, subtracted after its modeled tax cost and treated as nondeductible. The benchmark fee applies only to the hypothetical taxable equivalent. If your yield already includes a fee, enter only additional fees to avoid counting it twice. Fees can make net income and equivalent yields negative.

What happens at a 100% tax assumption?

A fully taxable benchmark keeps none of its gross income and nets minus its annual fee, regardless of gross yield. If that matches the alternative, every benchmark yield matches; otherwise no yield matches. The edge case is supported as a mathematical boundary, not a claim about your tax rate.

Are crossover intervals exact or estimated from the plot?

They are solved as exact intersections of linear inequalities over 0–100% tax. Boundaries include ties, including an alternative that leads only at a single tax rate. Very narrow intervals may be visually indistinguishable; the exact details and CSV retain their rational endpoints.

Does the highest net yield identify the best investment?

No. The comparison omits market-price changes, default, interest-rate risk, liquidity, reinvestment, compounding and individualized tax effects. Its result is conditional arithmetic for the entered assumptions. The highest modeled income yield is not a suitability or return guarantee.

Similar Calculators