Student Loan Refinance Comparison Calculator

Enter your current private fixed-rate education loans and one or two replacement quotes. Compare their first monthly payments, full repayment costs, and the cash paid by a common month. Include one-time fees paid upfront or added to the new principal to see how a longer term or lower note rate changes the result.

Fixed-rate private loans

Compare private student loan refinance quotes

See how different terms and fees affect monthly payments, interest and the amount paid at a common month.

Comparison timing

Month 0 is the refinance date. Use fixed nominal interest rates and model private loans with equal monthly dates.

Common-month comparison

Starting principal across current loans is $30,000.00. All options start together and use month 36 for comparison.

Keep current loans

$558.87

First monthly payment

Cash paid through month 36
$20,119.32
Remaining principal
$15,439.49
Cash plus remaining balance
$35,558.81
Lifetime interest
$7,266.77
Lifetime cash paid
$37,266.77
Loan payoff month
72

Quote A

$571.65

First monthly payment

Cash paid through month 36
$20,929.40
Remaining principal
$12,977.19
Cash plus remaining balance
$33,906.59
Change from keeping at month 36
-$1,652.22
Lifetime interest
$4,299.14
Lifetime cash paid
$34,649.14
Lifetime change from keeping
-$2,617.63
Loan payoff month
60

Quote B

$396.46

First monthly payment

Cash paid through month 36
$14,272.56
Remaining principal
$20,630.97
Cash plus remaining balance
$34,903.53
Change from keeping at month 36
-$655.28
Lifetime interest
$7,610.24
Lifetime cash paid
$38,060.24
Lifetime change from keeping
+$793.47
Loan payoff month
96

Cash plus balance is the amount paid so far plus the principal that would remain to close the loan in that month.

Month 36. Quote A cash plus balance change -$1,652.22. Quote B change -$655.28.

Repayment over time

The vertical guide marks the shared comparison month.

Cash plus remaining balance (USD)

Months since comparison start

  • Keep current loans, solid · $35,558.81 at month 36
  • Quote A, dashed · $33,906.59 at month 36
  • Quote B, dotted · $34,903.53 at month 36

Current private loans

Use principal balances from the same date. Each loan keeps its own fixed rate and remaining term.

Current loan 1
Current loan 2

Replacement quotes

Enter upfront fees paid in cash and financed fees added to the loan. Use the note rate before fees.

Quote A
Quote B
Show monthly comparison table

Export the comparison

Save the entered loan terms, fees and monthly payment, balance and interest ledgers in USD cents.

Show selectable CSV

How to use this calculator

  1. Start with Two-quote example or Same rate, different fees. Under Current private loans, enter each current principal, fixed annual note rate and remaining months.
  2. Enter the new term and fixed annual note rate for Quote A. Separate Upfront fees paid in cash from Financed fees added to principal. Enable Compare Quote B for another offer.
  3. Set Comparison month to the period you want to evaluate together. Month 0 shows the starting balance and cash fees.
  4. Read Common-month comparison to check first monthly payments, cash plus remaining balance, lifetime interest and total paid. In Repayment over time, choose the Chart measure to explore the tradeoff.
  5. Open Show monthly comparison table or Download refinance CSV to retain the input terms, horizon results and monthly ledger.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

The model starts every option on the same month 0. Continuing uses each current principal, note rate and remaining term separately. Each replacement loan starts with the sum of current principal plus that quote’s financed fees. Upfront fees are cash at month 0. Use the fixed nominal annual interest rate and enter fees separately.
For principal P, term n months and monthly rate r equal to the fixed nominal annual interest rate (as a percentage) divided by 1,200, the level principal-and-interest payment is P × r/[1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ]. At zero rate it is P/n. The schedule rounds the proposed payment and each month’s balance × r interest half-up to cents. Interest is paid before principal. The final modeled payment settles the remaining balance plus that month’s interest; payment stops when balance reaches zero. A tiny payment may round to zero before the final installment.
At comparison month h, cash paid includes upfront fees and all scheduled installments through h. Add the remaining principal at h to see cash plus remaining balance, an estimate of the total paid if closing the loan in that month under the model. This equals original principal plus both kinds of quoted fees and accrued modeled interest. Lifetime cash includes all payments and upfront fees. It captures financed fees through principal repayment. Positive differences mean more dollars than continuing the current loans.
Enter 1 to 8 current balances from $0.01 to $1,000,000 each. Fixed annual note rates support 0% to 30% to six decimal places. Current and replacement terms are 1 to 360 whole months. Each quoted fee supports $0 to $100,000 to cents. The common comparison month can be 0 to 360, including months after a loan has been paid off.
The model assumes fixed private loans, equal monthly dates, no extra payments, no unposted starting interest and no payoff charge. Actual loans may accrue interest daily or follow different schedules or fees. Entered terms represent a what-if comparison. Private refinancing and federal consolidation are separate financing paths with different terms and program rules.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Current private loans: $18,000 at 7.5% for 72 months and $12,000 at 8.75% for 60 months
  • Quote A: 5.4% for 60 months, $350 upfront fee
  • Quote B: 5.75% for 96 months, $450 financed fee
  • Comparison month: 36

Result:

Keeping both loans starts at $558.87 per month and costs $37,266.77 over their full terms. Quote A starts at $571.65 and costs $34,649.14. Quote B starts at $396.46 and costs $38,060.24. At month 36, cash plus remaining balance is $35,558.81 for keeping, $33,906.59 for Quote A and $34,903.53 for Quote B.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why can the quote with the lowest payment cost more?

A longer term spreads the balance over more payments. That can lower each month’s payment while increasing the total interest paid over the full term.

What is cash plus remaining balance?

It adds what you have paid through the selected month to the modeled unpaid principal. This compares options at a shared close date when their remaining balances differ.

How do upfront and financed fees differ in the calculation?

Upfront fees increase cash paid at month 0. Financed fees increase the opening loan principal and are repaid through the installments along with any associated interest.

Why can the current loan payment change over time?

Each existing loan keeps its own rate and remaining term. The combined payment can drop when one of the loans finishes, even while the others continue.

Should I enter the note rate or the fee-inclusive APR?

Enter the fixed nominal annual rate the lender charges on principal. The planner evaluates fees in their own fields so the interest and fee components appear separately.

Do private refinance quotes and federal consolidation work the same way?

They are different products and can have different repayment terms and protections. This worksheet models fixed-rate private quotes. Federal Student Aid describes federal consolidation and how it differs from private refinancing.

Similar Calculators