Equipment Lease vs Cash Purchase Planner

Compare three ways to use equipment over the same service period: buy it with cash, lease it and return it, or lease it and buy it out. Enter the actual quoted rent, payment timing, upfront charges, recurring costs and end-of-term assumptions. The workspace separates money paid and refunded from equipment value still owned, then discounts both for an economic comparison. Inspect monthly charts and ledgers, break-even rent and rent/value sensitivity before exporting your assumptions and exact results. This does not calculate a lender quote, classify a lease for accounting, determine tax benefits or establish which contract options are available.

Equipment finance studio

Compare the cash. Account for what you keep.

Compare cash purchase, lease return and lease buyout with transparent cash flows and retained equipment value.

Three paths to the same equipment horizon.

Enter quoted costs for one service period. Retained equipment value is an economic credit, not a cash sale. This comparison does not determine contract options, tax treatment or accounting classification.

Illustrative equipment quote · 36 months

Cash required and value retained

Economic cost subtracts the value of equipment still owned at the end. Present value (PV) also discounts future amounts using your 6% nominal annual assumption. Lower economic cost is not the same as lower upfront cash.

Cash purchase

PV economic cost
USD 40,217.75
Cash costs minus retained asset value, discounted
Net cash paid
USD 57,400
Retained asset value
USD 20,000
Cash due at month zero
USD 52,000
Total deposit refunded
USD 0

Lease and return

PV economic cost
USD 40,698.69
Cash costs minus retained asset value, discounted
Net cash paid
USD 43,980
Retained asset value
USD 0
Cash due at month zero
USD 4,000
Total deposit refunded
USD 3,000

PV economic saving versus cash: USD −480.93. This alternative has higher modeled economic cost.

Lease and buy out

PV economic cost
USD 31,924.42
Cash costs minus retained asset value, discounted
Net cash paid
USD 53,480
Retained asset value
USD 20,000
Cash due at month zero
USD 4,000
Total deposit refunded
USD 3,000

PV economic saving versus cash: USD 8,293.34. This alternative has lower modeled economic cost.

No equipment sale is assumed. The retained value reduces economic cost but never appears as a cash receipt. The deposit, by contrast, is assumed fully refunded in cash at the horizon.

Follow the timing of each alternative

Month zero includes upfront charges and any beginning-of-month rent. Operating costs occur at month end. Solid green: cash purchase. Dashed blue: lease and return. Dotted amber: lease and buy out. Points connect monthly snapshots, not daily transactions.

Cumulative net cash paid (USD)
Top: USD 57,400Bottom: USD 0
Cash paid over time, including deposit refunds. Equivalent monthly amounts are in the ledgers below.
Month 0Month 36
  • Cash purchase: USD 52,000 initially → USD 57,400 at the horizon.
  • Lease and return: USD 4,000 initially → USD 43,980 at the horizon.
  • Lease and buy out: USD 4,000 initially → USD 53,480 at the horizon.
Cumulative discounted economic cost (USD)
Top: USD 56,805.31Bottom: USD 0
Discounted economic cost, including the end-of-term retained-value credit. Equivalent monthly amounts are in the ledgers below.
Month 0Month 36
  • Cash purchase: USD 52,000 initially → USD 40,217.75 at the horizon.
  • Lease and return: USD 4,000 initially → USD 40,698.69 at the horizon.
  • Lease and buy out: USD 4,000 initially → USD 31,924.42 at the horizon.

Separate the asset credit from cash

Each outlined segment connects PV cash cost to PV economic cost by subtracting retained equipment value. All use a common scale from USD 0 to USD 56,930.65; the vertical line marks zero.

Cash purchase

USD 56,930.65 cash PV − USD 16,712.9 asset PV = USD 40,217.75 economic PV.

Lease and return

USD 40,698.69 cash PV − USD 0 asset PV = USD 40,698.69 economic PV.

Lease and buy out

USD 48,637.31 cash PV − USD 16,712.9 asset PV = USD 31,924.42 economic PV.

What monthly rent would tie cash purchase?

Lease and return

USD 1,085.37

Lower rent gives lower modeled economic cost than cash; higher rent gives higher cost, with all other assumptions held fixed.

Lease and buy out

USD 1,352.3

Lower rent gives lower modeled economic cost than cash; higher rent gives higher cost, with all other assumptions held fixed.

Stress-test rent and retained value

Each scenario varies only rent and retained value from your base inputs. Candidate amounts round to cents before comparison. This is not a forecast; ties are retained. The same retained value applies to cash purchase and lease-buyout.

PV economic costs by rent and retained-value scenario in USD
Rent / value multipliersMonthly rentRetained valueCash PV costReturn PV costBuyout PV costLowest modeled cost
50% / 0%550.000.0056,930.6522,619.6330,558.25Lease and return
75% / 0%825.000.0056,930.6531,659.1639,597.78Lease and return
100% / 0%1100.000.0056,930.6540,698.6948,637.31Lease and return
125% / 0%1375.000.0056,930.6549,738.2257,676.84Lease and return
150% / 0%1650.000.0056,930.6558,777.7566,716.37Cash purchase
50% / 50%550.0010000.0048,574.222,619.6322,201.81Lease and buy out
75% / 50%825.0010000.0048,574.231,659.1631,241.33Lease and buy out
100% / 50%1100.0010000.0048,574.240,698.6940,280.86Lease and buy out
125% / 50%1375.0010000.0048,574.249,738.2249,320.39Cash purchase
150% / 50%1650.0010000.0048,574.258,777.7558,359.92Cash purchase
50% / 100%550.0020000.0040,217.7522,619.6313,845.36Lease and buy out
75% / 100%825.0020000.0040,217.7531,659.1622,884.89Lease and buy out
100% / 100%1100.0020000.0040,217.7540,698.6931,924.42Lease and buy out
125% / 100%1375.0020000.0040,217.7549,738.2240,963.94Cash purchase
150% / 100%1650.0020000.0040,217.7558,777.7550,003.47Cash purchase
50% / 150%550.0030000.0031,861.322,619.635,488.91Lease and buy out
75% / 150%825.0030000.0031,861.331,659.1614,528.44Lease and buy out
100% / 150%1100.0030000.0031,861.340,698.6923,567.97Lease and buy out
125% / 150%1375.0030000.0031,861.349,738.2232,607.5Cash purchase
150% / 150%1650.0030000.0031,861.358,777.7541,647.02Cash purchase

Monthly cash and asset ledgers

Cash purchase
Cash purchase month-by-month values in USD
MonthPaidRefundNet cashRetained asset creditPV economic costCumulative net cashCumulative economic PV
052,000052,000052,00052,00052,000
115001500149.2552,15052,149.25
215001500148.5152,30052,297.76
315001500147.7752,45052,445.54
415001500147.0452,60052,592.57
515001500146.3152,75052,738.88
615001500145.5852,90052,884.46
715001500144.8553,05053,029.31
815001500144.1353,20053,173.44
915001500143.4253,35053,316.86
1015001500142.753,50053,459.56
1115001500141.9953,65053,601.55
1215001500141.2953,80053,742.84
1315001500140.5853,95053,883.42
1415001500139.8854,10054,023.31
1515001500139.1954,25054,162.49
1615001500138.554,40054,300.99
1715001500137.8154,55054,438.79
1815001500137.1254,70054,575.92
1915001500136.4454,85054,712.35
2015001500135.7655,00054,848.11
2115001500135.0855,15054,983.2
2215001500134.4155,30055,117.61
2315001500133.7455,45055,251.35
2415001500133.0855,60055,384.43
2515001500132.4255,75055,516.85
2615001500131.7655,90055,648.6
2715001500131.156,05055,779.7
2815001500130.4556,20055,910.15
2915001500129.856,35056,039.95
3015001500129.1556,50056,169.11
3115001500128.5156,65056,297.62
3215001500127.8756,80056,425.49
3315001500127.2456,95056,552.73
3415001500126.657,10056,679.33
3515001500125.9757,25056,805.31
36150015020,000−16,587.5557,40040,217.75
Lease and return
Lease and return month-by-month values in USD
MonthPaidRefundNet cashRetained asset creditPV economic costCumulative net cashCumulative economic PV
04,00004,00004,0004,0004,000
11,18001,18001,174.135,1805,174.13
21,18001,18001,168.296,3606,342.42
31,18001,18001,162.487,5407,504.89
41,18001,18001,156.698,7208,661.58
51,18001,18001,150.949,9009,812.52
61,18001,18001,145.2111,08010,957.73
71,18001,18001,139.5112,26012,097.25
81,18001,18001,133.8413,44013,231.09
91,18001,18001,128.214,62014,359.3
101,18001,18001,122.5915,80015,481.89
111,18001,18001,117.0116,98016,598.89
121,18001,18001,111.4518,16017,710.34
131,18001,18001,105.9219,34018,816.26
141,18001,18001,100.4220,52019,916.68
151,18001,18001,094.9421,70021,011.62
161,18001,18001,089.4922,88022,101.11
171,18001,18001,084.0724,06023,185.19
181,18001,18001,078.6825,24024,263.87
191,18001,18001,073.3126,42025,337.18
201,18001,18001,067.9727,60026,405.15
211,18001,18001,062.6628,78027,467.82
221,18001,18001,057.3729,96028,525.19
231,18001,18001,052.1131,14029,577.3
241,18001,18001,046.8832,32030,624.18
251,18001,18001,041.6733,50031,665.85
261,18001,18001,036.4934,68032,702.34
271,18001,18001,031.3335,86033,733.67
281,18001,18001,026.237,04034,759.87
291,18001,18001,021.138,22035,780.97
301,18001,18001,016.0239,40036,796.98
311,18001,18001,010.9640,58037,807.94
321,18001,18001,005.9341,76038,813.87
331,18001,18001,000.9342,94039,814.8
341,18001,1800995.9544,12040,810.75
351,18001,1800990.9945,30041,801.74
361,6803,000−1,3200−1,103.0543,98040,698.69
Lease and buy out
Lease and buy out month-by-month values in USD
MonthPaidRefundNet cashRetained asset creditPV economic costCumulative net cashCumulative economic PV
04,00004,00004,0004,0004,000
11,18001,18001,174.135,1805,174.13
21,18001,18001,168.296,3606,342.42
31,18001,18001,162.487,5407,504.89
41,18001,18001,156.698,7208,661.58
51,18001,18001,150.949,9009,812.52
61,18001,18001,145.2111,08010,957.73
71,18001,18001,139.5112,26012,097.25
81,18001,18001,133.8413,44013,231.09
91,18001,18001,128.214,62014,359.3
101,18001,18001,122.5915,80015,481.89
111,18001,18001,117.0116,98016,598.89
121,18001,18001,111.4518,16017,710.34
131,18001,18001,105.9219,34018,816.26
141,18001,18001,100.4220,52019,916.68
151,18001,18001,094.9421,70021,011.62
161,18001,18001,089.4922,88022,101.11
171,18001,18001,084.0724,06023,185.19
181,18001,18001,078.6825,24024,263.87
191,18001,18001,073.3126,42025,337.18
201,18001,18001,067.9727,60026,405.15
211,18001,18001,062.6628,78027,467.82
221,18001,18001,057.3729,96028,525.19
231,18001,18001,052.1131,14029,577.3
241,18001,18001,046.8832,32030,624.18
251,18001,18001,041.6733,50031,665.85
261,18001,18001,036.4934,68032,702.34
271,18001,18001,031.3335,86033,733.67
281,18001,18001,026.237,04034,759.87
291,18001,18001,021.138,22035,780.97
301,18001,18001,016.0239,40036,796.98
311,18001,18001,010.9640,58037,807.94
321,18001,18001,005.9341,76038,813.87
331,18001,18001,000.9342,94039,814.8
341,18001,1800995.9544,12040,810.75
351,18001,1800990.9945,30041,801.74
3611,1803,0008,18020,000−9,877.3253,48031,924.42

Keep the assumptions with the comparison

  • Three alternatives share one monthly service horizon: cash purchase, quoted lease returned at end, and quoted lease bought out at end. These alternatives are comparisons, not assertions that a contract permits each option.
  • Enter the complete quoted rent; it is not inferred from an interest rate. Rental payments occur at beginning or end as selected; recurring operating costs always occur at month end.
  • Purchase and upfront costs occur at month zero. The lease deposit is paid at zero and fully refunded at the horizon in both lease alternatives; partial forfeiture is not modeled.
  • Return pays the entered return cost and retains no asset. Buyout pays the entered buyout cost, without also paying the return cost, and retains the same entered asset value as cash purchase.
  • Terminal retained asset value is an economic credit, not cash received from a sale. Net cash cost and ownership-adjusted economic cost are reported separately.
  • The nominal annual discount percentage is divided by 12. Each month’s cash and terminal asset value is discounted by (1 + monthly discount rate) raised to the month number.
  • A positive PV saving means a lease alternative has lower modeled ownership-adjusted economic cost than cash purchase. Negative break-even rent means no nonnegative rent can meet or beat cash under the entered assumptions.
  • Sensitivity varies only quoted rent and retained asset value. Candidate inputs round to cents, half up, before exact comparisons; unsupported values above the input bounds are marked unavailable. These are scenarios, not forecasts.
  • No tax deductions, loan-funded purchase, accounting classification, automatic renewals, market rates or guaranteed asset value are inferred. Include known applicable charges consistently in your inputs.
  • Model calculations retain exact rational values without internal cent rounding. CSV preserves exact fractions, inputs, model results and sensitivity scenarios; formula-like text receives an apostrophe prefix.

How to use this calculator

  1. Load End-of-month rent example or Advance rent example, then open Edit equipment and quote assumptions. Set the label, currency, comparison months and nominal annual discount assumption.
  2. Enter the cash price, purchase upfront costs and monthly operating costs. Enter the same equipment service horizon used for the lease.
  3. Enter quoted monthly rent, its beginning/end timing, lease upfront charges, fully refundable deposit and recurring costs not already included in rent.
  4. Enter separate return and buyout costs and the value you expect to retain if the equipment is owned at the horizon. Apply comparison.
  5. Compare net cash paid with discounted economic cost, inspect monthly charts and ledgers, and review break-even rent and sensitivity. Download equipment CSV or use its selectable copy.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

Use one currency and a service horizon of N whole months. Compare cash purchase, lease-and-return and lease-and-buyout. All amounts are entered assumptions. Quoted rent is an input; no lease payment is inferred from a financing rate.
Cash purchase pays equipment price plus purchase upfront costs at month 0. Purchase operating costs occur at months 1 through N. Retained equipment value is credited economically at month N, but no sale or cash receipt is assumed.
Both lease alternatives pay lease upfront costs and the refundable deposit at month 0. The full deposit is refunded at month N. With end-of-month rent, N payments occur at months 1 through N; with beginning-of-month rent, they occur at months 0 through N−1. There is no extra advance payment. Lease operating costs always occur at months 1 through N.
Lease-and-return pays returnCost at month N and retains no asset. Lease-and-buyout instead pays buyoutCost at N and retains the same entered terminal asset value as cash purchase; it does not also pay returnCost. These are alternative economic scenarios, not a claim that a particular agreement permits both.
For each monthly row, paid = upfront charges + deposit paid + rent + operating costs + terminal charge. Net cash = paid − deposit refund. Economic cost = net cash − retained asset value. The asset credit appears only at the horizon and is not cash received.
Monthly discount d = nominal annual discount percentage / 1200. Weight at month t is (1 + d)^−t. PV cash cost = sum(net cash at t × weight at t). PV retained asset = retained value × weight at N. PV economic cost = PV cash cost − PV retained asset. At a zero discount rate, present values equal undiscounted values. A refundable deposit has zero undiscounted net cost but can have a positive present-value opportunity cost.
PV economic saving of a lease alternative = cash purchase PV economic cost − lease PV economic cost. Positive means a lower modeled economic cost for that lease; negative means a higher cost. This is not necessarily cash saved in the bank. Negative economic costs are allowed when entered retained value exceeds the discounted costs.
Let R be the sum of discount weights at all rental-payment times. Break-even quoted monthly rent = (cash PV economic cost − lease PV economic cost excluding rent) / R. All other assumptions remain fixed. A negative threshold means no nonnegative rent can meet or beat cash purchase under these inputs. Preserve exact ties rather than choosing a winner arbitrarily.
Sensitivity uses rent at 50%, 75%, 100%, 125% and 150% of entered rent and retained value at 0%, 50%, 100% and 150% of entered value. Candidate inputs round to cents, half up, before exact comparison. Candidates above the monetary limit are marked unavailable. Changes in rent affect lease PV by rent change × R; changes in retained value reduce cash and buyout PV equally by value change × horizon weight. The grid is a scenario comparison, not a forecast.
Limits: N is 1–120 whole months. Cash price is greater than zero through 1,000,000,000; other money inputs are 0–1,000,000,000, with at most two decimals. Nominal annual discount is 0–100% with at most six decimals. Numeric drafts are unsigned plain decimals of at most 30 characters; blanks, signs, exponents, commas and excess precision are invalid. Currency is a 1–12 character label and the comparison label has 1–100 characters.
Cash and present-value arithmetic retains exact fractions without internal cent rounding. Display rounds half away from zero and retains a tiny fraction when ordinary rounding would hide a nonzero result. CSV preserves complete inputs, model results and sensitivity scenarios; formula-like text is prefixed with an apostrophe.
No loan-funded purchase, partial deposit forfeiture, automatic renewals, variable rent, tax deductions, accounting classification, market valuation or contract rights are modeled. Include known charges consistently and avoid double-counting maintenance already included in rent. An opportunity-cost discount assumption is not a contractual APR.
Sources reviewed November 13, 2026: Microsoft documents present-value conventions and beginning/end-of-period payments. Western Equipment Finance describes differing purchase, return and buyout structures. Those sources support the concepts; they do not validate any entered quote, asset value or contractual choice.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Horizon: 36 months, USD, 6% nominal annual discount (0.5% monthly); rent at month end.
  • Cash purchase: USD 50,000 price, USD 2,000 upfront costs and USD 150 monthly operating costs.
  • Lease quote: USD 1,100 monthly rent, USD 1,000 upfront costs, USD 3,000 fully refundable deposit and USD 80 monthly operating costs.
  • End of term: USD 500 return cost or USD 10,000 buyout cost. An owned asset retains USD 20,000 of value; no sale is assumed.

Result:

Cash purchase pays USD 52,000 initially plus 36 × USD 150, giving USD 57,400 net cash paid. Lease-and-return pays USD 1,000 + 36 × (1,100 + 80) + USD 500 = USD 43,980 after the deposit refund. Lease-buyout instead pays USD 53,480 net cash. At 0.5% monthly discount, the 36 month-end payment weights sum to about 32.871016 and the terminal weight is about 0.835645. Cash PV is about USD 56,930.65; subtract USD 16,712.90 retained-value PV for USD 40,217.75 economic PV. Return economic PV is USD 40,698.69, about USD 480.93 more than cash. Buyout economic PV is USD 31,924.42, about USD 8,293.34 less than cash. Break-even rent is about USD 1,085.37 for return or USD 1,352.30 for buyout, with other assumptions fixed. Retained value is an economic credit, not a cash refund.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the planner calculate an equipment lease payment from an interest rate?

No. Enter the actual quoted monthly rent. The discount percentage is an opportunity-cost assumption used to compare timing, not an inferred lease APR.

Why is retained asset value separate from cash flow?

Equipment still owned has economic value, but retaining it does not put cash in the bank. The planner credits that value only in economic cost; no sale is assumed.

Why does a fully refundable deposit affect present value?

The money leaves at month zero and returns later. At a positive discount rate, the later refund is worth less in present-value terms. Undiscounted net deposit cost is zero.

How are advance payments handled?

Beginning timing places exactly N rental payments at months 0 through N−1. End timing places N payments at months 1 through N. Neither adds an extra payment; operating costs stay at month end.

Does buyout also include the return cost?

No. Return and buyout are separate end-of-term alternatives. Return pays its entered charge and retains no asset; buyout pays its charge and retains the entered equipment value.

What does a negative break-even rent mean?

The fixed costs and retained-value assumptions already favor cash enough that no nonnegative rent can match it. The mathematical threshold remains negative; the planner does not replace it with zero.

Why does changing retained value not alter the cash-versus-buyout difference?

Both alternatives retain the same entered asset value at the same horizon, so that credit cancels in their difference. It still affects comparisons with lease-and-return, which retains no asset.

Does a lower modeled cost mean I should sign that lease?

No. This comparison does not establish contract options, tax treatment, financing availability, equipment condition or operational suitability. It evaluates the declared costs and retained-value assumptions.

Similar Calculators