Electricity Bill & Rate Comparison Calculator

Compare two electricity rate plans for the same billing period and total kWh. Enter the period's prices and service charges for flat, time-of-use or cumulative tier pricing. Move a share of peak consumption to off-peak hours and see when the cheaper plan changes. The graph, bill breakdown and CSV show the energy and fee components behind each total. Bring rates and tier cutoffs that apply to your billing period, and use the same time bands for both plans.

Electricity billing

Electricity tariff comparison

Compare two bills on the same kWh, then measure the effect of moving peak usage.

Billing period and usage

Use the same time bands for both plans. Enter the rates and cutoffs for this billing period. The example prices are illustrative.

Plan A

Plan B

Plan A $106.50, plan B $90.30 after shifting.

Estimated bills

500 kWh in 30 days. Move 90 kWh from peak to off-peak.

Plan A · Flat example

With recorded usage
$106.50
After shifting usage
$106.50
Bill reduction
$0.00

Plan B · Time-of-use example

With recorded usage
$114.60
After shifting usage
$90.30
Bill reduction
$24.30

Plan A is lower by $8.10 with recorded usage. Plan B is lower by $16.20 after the shift.

Bill cost as you move peak usage

Plan totals by kilowatt-hours shiftedThe visible cost scale runs from $68.43 to $120.27. Move from zero to 150 peak kWh into off-peak.
Plan A · solid linePlan B · dashed line

Horizontal scale from 0 to 150 kWh shifted. Vertical scale from $68.43 to $120.27 per bill.

The plans tie at 30 kWh shifted.

Shift and bill values
Shift (kWh)Plan APlan B
0$106.50$114.60
7.5$106.50$112.58
15$106.50$110.55
22.5$106.50$108.53
30$106.50$106.50
37.5$106.50$104.48
45$106.50$102.45
52.5$106.50$100.43
60$106.50$98.40
67.5$106.50$96.38
75$106.50$94.35
82.5$106.50$92.33
90$106.50$90.30
97.5$106.50$88.28
105$106.50$86.25
112.5$106.50$84.23
120$106.50$82.20
127.5$106.50$80.18
135$106.50$78.15
142.5$106.50$76.13
150$106.50$74.10

Bill component ledger

ComponentRateRecorded quantityShifted quantityRecorded costShifted cost
Flat energy charge0.18 USD/kWh500 kWh500 kWh$90.00$90.00
Per-bill charge12 USD/bill1 bill1 bill$12.00$12.00
Daily charges0.15 USD/day30 day30 day$4.50$4.50
Total before display rounding$106.50$106.50

Totals use unrounded charges. For additional digits, export the ledger.

How to use this calculator

  1. Enter Billing days and the measured Off-peak use, Mid-peak use and Peak use for that period. Use the same nonoverlapping time bands for both plans. Enter zero for an unused band.
  2. Set Pricing under Plan A and Plan B to Flat rate, Time of use or Cumulative tiers. Copy each plan's rates in USD/kWh and add the Per-bill charge and Daily charge that apply to this period.
  3. For Cumulative tiers, enter each Tier through cutoff for this bill and its Tier rate. Leave the final tier as All remaining kWh. Select Add time charges to the tier base only when the rate sheet lists separate per-kWh time adders for the same usage.
  4. Set Move from peak to off-peak between zero and your starting peak use. Inspect the resulting bills, the Bill cost as you move peak usage chart, and any tie. Use the bill breakdown to check the contribution of each fee, band or tier.
  5. Use Download electricity bill CSV to keep the comparison, including the original and shifted bills and the tested shift points. Show selectable CSV displays the same data for copying.

The Formula

The mathematical logic powering this calculation is:

Total energy E is the sum of off-peak, mid-peak and peak kWh. A flat plan multiplies E by its energy rate. A time-of-use plan adds the three products of band kWh and that band's USD/kWh rate.

Cumulative tier pricing divides total kWh into consecutive blocks. Each bounded tier receives the smaller of its width and the kWh remaining after the earlier tiers. For cutoffs of 200 and 400 kWh, the first two blocks are each 200 kWh wide. The last tier gets every kWh remaining. The tiered energy charge is the sum of each block's kWh times its rate. If Add time charges to the tier base is selected, a second charge applies each band's adder to all kWh in that band. Every band still draws from the same ladder of total-energy tiers.

The modeled bill is the energy charge plus the per-bill charge plus billing days times the daily charge. Use the rates and already-prorated tier cutoffs for the period under comparison. A charge stated in cents per kWh must be entered in USD per kWh. For example, 18 cents per kWh is 0.18 USD/kWh.

For a shift of s kWh, peak falls by s and off-peak rises by s. Mid-peak kWh, total energy and tier allocations stay fixed. A plan's savings per shifted kWh equals its peak time rate minus off-peak time rate. Those time rates are both zero for a flat plan and for tiers without time adders. A negative difference means shifting increases that plan's bill. The difference between plan B and plan A varies linearly with the shift. Solving for a zero difference gives a tie when it lies between zero and the original peak use. When the theoretical tie falls between 0.001 kWh inputs, the result gives the two adjacent usable shift values.

Enter 1–366 whole billing days and nonnegative decimal energy with up to three places. Each initial band supports up to 10,000 kWh, and the shift cannot exceed peak use. A tiered plan supports one to eight tiers with positive, strictly increasing cutoffs up to 30,000 kWh. The final tier is open-ended. Energy rates and service charges accept up to six decimal places. The model uses unrounded charges to compare bills. Displayed currency typically rounds to cents.

The examples use illustrative inputs. This comparison covers the entered energy and service charges. Separate ladders by time band, automatic billing calendars and allowances, taxes, demand charges, minimum bills, riders, credits and export payments are outside its scope.

Worked Example

If you input:

  • Billing days: 30 days
  • Off-peak use: 260 kWh
  • Mid-peak use: 90 kWh
  • Peak use: 150 kWh
  • Move from peak to off-peak: 90 kWh
  • Plan A Pricing: Flat rate
  • Plan A Flat energy rate: 0.18 USD/kWh
  • Plan A Per-bill charge: $12.00
  • Plan A Daily charge: $0.15/day
  • Plan B Pricing: Time of use
  • Plan B Off-peak rate: 0.11 USD/kWh
  • Plan B Mid-peak rate: 0.20 USD/kWh
  • Plan B Peak rate: 0.38 USD/kWh
  • Plan B Per-bill charge: $8.00
  • Plan B Daily charge: $0.10/day

Result:

The three bands total 500 kWh. Plan A bills 500 × $0.18 plus $12.00 and 30 × $0.15, for $106.50. Plan B bills 260 × $0.11, 90 × $0.20 and 150 × $0.38, plus $8.00 and 30 × $0.10, for $114.60. Moving 90 kWh saves $24.30 on Plan B because each shifted kWh moves from $0.38 to $0.11. Plan A stays at $106.50 and Plan B drops to $90.30. The plans tie at 30 kWh shifted because Plan B's starting $8.10 difference divided by $0.27 per kWh is 30 kWh.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use two plans with different peak hours?

Use one set of time bands for both plans. A flat rate can be compared with any set of bands because its price is constant. If two time-varying plans use boundaries that cannot be represented by the same three groups, this calculator cannot price both correctly from a single set of totals.

What is the difference between a tier cutoff and a tier's size?

A cutoff is cumulative usage at the end of a tier. Two 200 kWh blocks have cutoffs at 200 kWh and 400 kWh. The cutoff that applies to your bill may depend on the billing period, season or allowance. Check the utility's applicable cutoff before entering it.

When should I add time charges to cumulative tiers?

Use time adders when your rate sheet applies a base charge to each tier of total energy and a separate per-kWh adder for each time band. Use Time of use when the band prices already represent the full per-kWh energy rates. A tariff with separate tier ladders for each band needs a different calculation.

What does moving peak use change?

Every kWh you move lowers peak use by one and increases off-peak use by one. The calculator keeps the same billing days and total energy. It calculates the rate effect of that transfer. Whether appliances, vehicle charging or storage can move that much use depends on your actual schedule and equipment.

Why does the chart sometimes show no tie?

One plan can cost less throughout the feasible shift range. Equal savings per shifted kWh means the initial cost difference stays constant. If the two plans start equal and stay equal across the available range, every feasible shift is a tie.

Why are two shift values shown around a tie?

Shift entries support thousandths of a kWh. A mathematical tie can fall between two entries, so the calculator shows the adjacent feasible amounts and indicates which plan wins on each side. Rounded bills can also appear equal to the cent while the model still finds a difference.

Why might my utility bill differ?

Utilities may use taxes, riders, demand charges, minimum bills, changing seasons or export credits. Enter actual energy rates, cutoffs and included service charges for the period. Use the result to compare those terms and verify the full tariff separately.

Similar Calculators